News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by tehjoker on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:33PM (#25151939)
They moved from an objective definition to a subjective definition of "expertise". Expect many more regular people to be scammed out of their life savings.
Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by dragonwriter on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:52PM (#25152157)
> They moved from an objective definition to a subjective definition of "expertise".

No, they didn't. It remains objective, it just now tests expertise by objective standards, not merely wealth or income. (Which are, at best, more distant proxies for expertise than the new ones.)

> Expect many more regular people to be scammed out of their life savings.

The new added standards are less "regular people" than the the old, continued standards, so I don't think that's the case. If licensed professional investment advisors and the like are getting scammed out of their life savings because they are able to invest directly in unlicensed securities, than there is a real problem with the licensing systems or the process allowing the investments to be offered at all, regardless of investor qualifications.

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by throwawaygh on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:13PM (#25152420)
> The new added standards are less "regular people" than the the old, continued standards

I generally agree with your comment, but this doesn't make much sense. The old "$200K/300K or $1MM outside primary residence" standards are continued, right? So by definition, in raw numbers, there could only ever be at least as many "regular people"...

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by dragonwriter on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:23PM (#25152565)
I'm not saying their are fewer "regular people" in total (which, as you note, would be impossible, since this only adds new categories, rather than narrowing or eliminating old ones). I am saying that the new categories are less "regular people" than the existing, continuing ones, and are not opening up risk to regular people. The risk to "regular" people who are unsophisticated in investing is almost entirely in the old categories.
Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by DennisP on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:39PM (#25152017)
Before August their "objective definition" was just having money. Having money doesn't make you a good investor. Dentists for example are notoriously bad investors, but prior to the change were less "protected" than a person with less money who's certified as an investment advisor.
Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by jonathankoren on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:00PM (#25152251)
I think you’re looking at this wrong. This rule was originally created in 1933 to mitigating societal economic risk.

The reason why having money was the objective definition was because defining expertise objectively is difficult. (What are you going to do? Have a standardized test?) This problem still remains.

Like you said, having money doesn’t make you a savvy investor. However, you can typically absorb the losses with comparatively less pain. Also, since you have more money, you can make more investments, which means you gain experience, and thus hopefully better at avoiding bad investments.

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by DennisP on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:04PM (#25153097)
Funny you should say that because they do have standardized tests. Any of three certifications qualifies you.

The other non-financial individual qualification is also objective. Are you a certain type of employee of an investment firm? If so you can invest in that firm. None of this is subjective.

If this were about whether you can absorb losses, then it would limit the investment amount based on your financial capacity, like the JOBS Act does. There's nothing stopping a millionaire from throwing too much of their savings into questionable investments, and plenty of millionaires have gone broke doing exactly that. They probably would have been better off if they had to pass those standardized tests first, like us po' folks are able to do now.

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by jonathankoren on Thursday November 19, 2020 @05:02PM (#25154890)
Ironically, the accredited investor income and net worth criteria haven’t been updated since 1983. If the criteria has been indexed to inflation, you’d need a salary of $530k or a net worth of $2.6M.
Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by CalChris on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:49PM (#25152127)
However, they didn't tighten the definition to prevent rich dentists from making bad decisions. They are loosening it which will allow even poor dentists to make bad decisions.
Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by dragonwriter on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:53PM (#25152165)
> They are loosening it which will allow even poor dentists to make bad decisions.

Um, under what part of the new standard would a "poor dentist" that would not qualify under the old standard qualify?

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by CalChris on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:22PM (#25152556)
natural persons holding in good standing one or more professional certifications or designations or other credentials from an accredited educational institution

However, it is not possible to say since this class of professional certifications is not delineated. Dentistry may qualify. It may not.

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by dragonwriter on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:35PM (#25152725)
> However, it is not possible to say since this class of professional certifications is not delineated.

Yes, it is quite specifically. The new rule also sets out standards (which would very much not seem to be likely to ever admit certification in dentistry) and a process for subsequent rulemaking to update the set of certifications, but any problem with certifications later adopted would be an issue with those actions, not the immediate action.

The initial set is "the General Securities Representative license (Series 7), the Private Securities Offerings Representative license (Series 82), and the Licensed Investment Adviser Representative (Series 65)". [https://www.sec.gov/rules/final/2020/33-10824.pdf, bottom of p. 28]

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by vonmoltke on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:42PM (#25152833)
> natural persons holding in good standing one or more professional certifications or designations or other credentials from an accredited educational institution

You cut off the critical second half of that statement, which significantly changes the meaning:

> natural persons holding in good standing one or more professional certifications or designations or other credentials from an accredited educational institution that the Commission has designated as qualifying an individual for accredited investor status

If you think the SEC would add DDS to that list, I'm not sure why you would trust them to regulate investing at all.

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by tptacek on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:38PM (#25152768)
You've misunderstood the rule. It's not arbitrary professional certifications. It's those certifications the SEC designates, which right now are the Series 7 and Series 65. Nobody is going to automatically accredit dentists.
Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by typenil on Thursday November 19, 2020 @02:55PM (#25153656)
This kind of elitist nonsense where people say "Accredited Investor" as if it implied some kind of education or certification.

It was always just a certification that you had an excessive amount wealth.

Sounds like you believe someone with a net worth of $900k or a salary of $190k is objectively incompetent become they're barely under the threshold.

"Objective definition." What a joke.

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by tehjoker on Thursday November 19, 2020 @03:10PM (#25153791)
Right. It means when you invest in random ass companies and you get scammed, you can afford to lose the money. Someone with less money getting scammed with visions of dollar signs in their eyes isn't playing a bourgeois parlor game, they're playing with their housing, job, car, etc.

To me, the previous SEC rule is just an acknowledgment of the real aristocratic underpinnings of an advanced capitalist economy.

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by gojomo on Thursday November 19, 2020 @03:17PM (#25153859)
Regular people who want to lose their life savings can still do so via overleveraged real estate, investing informally in small businesses, margin daytrading, sports betting, purchasing vanity higher education credentials, and nowadays, cryptocurrencies/cryptotokens.

So, this won't cause any more people to lose money, but it may change the mix of things they lose it on.

And because this will also open to non-wealthy people many good deals in above-board companies, that have been scrupulously following the law & attracting rich sophisticated investors, it will also benefit those well-behaved companies and their less-rich friends, family, supporters, & customers – a win for society.

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by johndevor on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:46PM (#25152087)
> Expect many more regular people to be scammed out of their life savings.

People get scammed all the time in a million different ways.

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by xwdv on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:34PM (#25151952)
People are more savvy these days than the old days. This can help more than it hurts.
Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by joosters on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:45PM (#25152077)
Any evidence for this? The stats seem to show the opposite, e.g. there has been 3x as much money lost to ponzi schemes pre -> post-Madoff :https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/22/business/ponzi-scheme-ber...
Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by gojomo on Thursday November 19, 2020 @03:21PM (#25153898)
Indeed - and neither the accredited investor law nor the SEC's other enforcement have helped.

So maybe letting non-wealthy people invest into the exact same well-documented, scrupulously-legal above-board deals in which wealthier people have always been allowed to invest could be better than the traditional-but-totally-failing paternalism?

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by dragonwriter on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:05PM (#25152307)
> People are more savvy these days than the old days.

As compared to the complexity of available investment schemes, no, they probably aren't.

On the other hand, "licensed investment advisors and people currently working in investment-related roles in financial firms" are probably more savvy about investing, as a class, than "people who happen to have more than $1M in assets or $200K in personal or 300K in personal+spouse income".

Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by AlexandrB on Thursday November 19, 2020 @12:56PM (#25152197)
Re:The SEC “Modernizes” the Accredited Investor Definition by joshmn on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:14PM (#25152432)
I'd beg to differ. It seems to me that these days, a domain name, WordPress install, and Facebook allows for anyone to be an expert or whistleblower anything and everything.