Re:Kurzweil: 3 Supplements To Let You Live Until The Singula...
by michaelbuckbee on Wednesday May 04, 2011 @04:09PM
(#2515098)
The "eating foods, mostly plants, not too much" is a Michael Pollan line. One of Pollan's many points is that there is quite a bit of difficulty in separating out the good stuff from the bad stuff in foods due to chemical interactions.
His general reasoning is along the lines of "There are x thousand different chemical compounds in an orange, it's very difficult to say, well it's the Vitamin C that's the important one." (scurvy notwithstanding)
A good example of something like that is B12 and Iron Deficiency. You can be ingesting a good amount of Iron supplements but not have your actual Iron levels increase much if you lack B12.
That's not to say that there aren't some pretty clear wins (Vitamin D comes to mind) from taking supplements, just that the actual benefits are often less clear than some of the literature would state.
His general reasoning is along the lines of "There are x thousand different chemical compounds in an orange, it's very difficult to say, well it's the Vitamin C that's the important one." (scurvy notwithstanding)
A good example of something like that is B12 and Iron Deficiency. You can be ingesting a good amount of Iron supplements but not have your actual Iron levels increase much if you lack B12.
http://www.netdoctor.co.uk/diseases/facts/anaemiab12.htm
That's not to say that there aren't some pretty clear wins (Vitamin D comes to mind) from taking supplements, just that the actual benefits are often less clear than some of the literature would state.