It could have been breached recently that's true. But not for a website I currently use. I switched off those old emails and I am currently only using aliases (I know it's not very helpful without a list of websites I use).
The other thing I do is that I monitor failed smtp connection attempts to my mail server, particularly when they use one of these unique email aliases. That gives me advanced notice that the website has been breached, and I have quite a few that are not on HIBP's radar.
Re:The Cit0Day Breach Collection
by PaulStatezny on Thursday November 19, 2020 @10:14AM
(#25150305)
They are saying that all of the leaked data has been leaked in the past in other breaches. And because every account has a unique address, this suggests that it doesn't contain newly leaked information.
Or are you saying that you registered multiple times on the same website and the leak only contains the old registrations?