Re:I should have loved biology
by ufo on Thursday November 19, 2020 @06:47AM
(#25148562)
There is one important part of taxonomy that is not arbitrary, however. The classification should be hierarchical, reflecting the evolution of the tree of life.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
That's absolutely arbitrary too. The tree of life is a lie.
...or at least a very simplified model that breaks down as you move towards simpler and simpler forms of life. That's because horizontal gene transfer is a thing, and when you go all the way back to prokaryotes, there's so much of it going on that any "tree of life" is a statistical picture that's valid only for a select genetic marker that's used to trace dependencies. Pick a different marker, you'll get an entirely different prokaryotic tree of life.
Life ultimately forms a graph