Re:Linus Torvalds Interview for LinuxFR
by Raphael_Amiard on Wednesday May 04, 2011 @10:57AM
(#2514013)
To reiterate, even if murder is universally considered as being wrong, other issues such as property, copyright, profit and a lot of other things are treated extremely differently in different cultures.
So it's as easy to find something we all mostly agree on (murder) than something we all mostly disagree on (property).
Also taking the murder example is quite dishonest. Linus wasn't talking about murder issues. He was talking about intellectual property issues. Do you claim there is objective right and wrong in this domain ? Do you claim to know what it is ?
EDIT : Didn't see your edit, so correction about the "dishonest argument" part :)
FWIW, even killing people is/was considered acceptable: if the victims have property X where X varies between having the wrong race, being the firs born girl, being physically impaired, being sentenced to death, being a sacrificial offer and plenty more.
He's a US citizen now so it's called targeted killing when it's not wrong :)
Edit: OTOH, Linus is talking in the context of software licenses -- I agree with him that it can get holier-than-thou the way some folks push the GPL (not least its original author).