News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Krebsonsecurity.com has an expired SSL certificate by paxys on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @09:09PM (#25132381)
Why should every browser pick a random expiration date to enforce when there is already one agreed upon by everyone and embedded in the certificate?
Re:Krebsonsecurity.com has an expired SSL certificate by t0astbread on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @10:01PM (#25132723)
There might be an official standardized explanation for this but the way I see it, certificate expiry has two reasons:

1) It's an assurance that the verification of identities/servers (or whatever) behind the certificate is at least somewhat recent

2) Certificates imply a loose agreement between the certificate holder and the world that the certificate holder keeps the private key safe. The expiry date automatically ends that agreement.

Time is relevant in both cases but it's not that relevant that the timing is exact in web browsing. Identity verification is still about as fresh one day after expiry. The second case is a bit more critical but chances are certificate holders don't leak their private keys immediately after expiry.

Giving a "grace period" with noticeable but non-blocking warnings (something like the "this site recently had an account breach" popup in Firefox perhaps) might cause website operators to find out about the problem without disrupting the service. It would be a good idea to standardize the length of the grace period.

Off the top of my head I can only think of one situation that might turn problematic and that is when an expired certificate gets compromised. I'm not familiar with how CAs do it but I hope renewal automatically revokes the renewed certificate already. It would also need to be possible to explicitly revoke an expired certificate if something like a grace period existed.

Re:Krebsonsecurity.com has an expired SSL certificate by im3w1l on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @09:14PM (#25132409)
Everyone is on lets encrypt nowadays, which means they had no say in they expiration date. They merely said yes to "take it or leave it".
Re:Krebsonsecurity.com has an expired SSL certificate by aeyes on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @09:29PM (#25132523)
Let's Encrypt users aren't going to have cert expiration problems though, the certs expire every 90 days forcing users to implement auto renewal from the very beginning.

Let's Encrypt provides tools to do it while cert renewal with other certificate authorities is manual in most cases.

Re:Krebsonsecurity.com has an expired SSL certificate by im3w1l on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @09:45PM (#25132625)
I have personally experienced letsencrypt auto renewal failures. And I know other people on whose hobbyist servers it has failed too.

I don't remember how it happened - maybe it was user error, but even so it only manifested 3 months after set up, which is not always the most convenient time. And then it's 3 more months to see if the fix truly worked.

Re:Krebsonsecurity.com has an expired SSL certificate by apple4ever on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @12:39AM (#25133576)
Same here. In my case it was a failure of my DNS providers API and lack of monitoring. Worked fine at first, failed eventually.