News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Record Labels: Focus on Buyers, Not Thieves by barrkel on Wednesday May 04, 2011 @12:11AM (#2512774)
I bought Portal 2, I got bored of it after the few hours of gameplay it has, and I wanted to let my girlfriend play it (who has just finished Portal 1). Can't do that without giving her my login.

That alone means Steam games are worth perhaps only 30% of retail price to me; but they are not priced like that in the UK. They're usually 10-30% more expensive than e.g. Amazon.

These are the biggest kinds of problems I have with DRM, when it's not something like Securom complaining that I'm running Process Explorer.

[deleted]
Re:Dear Record Labels: Focus on Buyers, Not Thieves by barrkel on Wednesday May 04, 2011 @01:12AM (#2512869)
You of course realize, not all contract terms are binding, yet when contract terms are implemented in software, they become much more binding than when they are interpreted by a court of law.

You also realize that not all license agreements are the same; and first sale doctrine normally gives right to resell copyrighted works. I would in effect be gifting the game to my girlfriend, rather than lending it, as I wouldn't be playing it again.

And thanks for accusing me of breaking the law. I appreciate it.

(The thing that tipped me into buying the game on Steam was that I'd also be supporting independent developers with the Potato Sack etc.)

Re:Dear Record Labels: Focus on Buyers, Not Thieves by cookiecaper on Wednesday May 04, 2011 @01:13AM (#2512870)
First of all, please don't conflate license agreement and statute -- a statute is law, a license agreement is a private contract that may or may not be valid.

The US has until recently had strong case law support for lending and reselling goods. Look up the first sale doctrine, which states that copyright holders can only impose restrictions on the first sale of a copyrighted project, and thereafter the property can be used, sold, abused, denigrated, etc., as desired by the possessor. This is actually a really important part of copyright law, because without it a copyright holder could say "You can't give my CD to charity, I don't make money for poor people" (manifest practically as "you must not charge less than x price"), and otherwise impose ridiculous restrictions on private property, thereby diminishing the real property of the possessor in favor of the theorized intellectual property assigned to the copyright holder in order to promote useful progress in the arts. To the extent that copyright powers do not promote useful progress in the arts, they should be entirely demolished!!!