Otherwise yes, I know you can relatively easily lose work with git stash (I actually once lost about 2-4 days of work with a P4 shelve, which is an extremely similar feature), but it still seems easier to me than committing and then cleaning up history/resetting if you change your mind about the implementation...
Perhaps I will give this commit/reset workflow a try as well, to see how it feels. It may also be that committing still feels to much like "an event" for me, from my P4 days.
Aside from that, I hear you, git’s model is fundamentally different from Perforce. There’s no choice about whether you need a clean work tree before pulling, that’s simply a git requirement. So the main thing to ask now is what workflow you want and what safety net you want underneath it. On one side, the best way to focus is to not pull anything while you’re working and have a dirty work tree. But things come up at work, that’s not always realistic, so the next question is how to make the workflow both safe and also instinctual so that it doesn’t have friction.
I do think there’s something to your notion that commit feels more serious and heavy than stash, and that is something I personally have tried to break down. In git, commits and branches can be so much more lightweight, fluid and flexible, but it takes practice and fluency in git to be able to actually feel that.
It might be worth considering some shell or git aliases to do common things. You could easily alias a command that commits your work in progress with a comment “WIP”, and never have to type it. You can do the same with a branch and even keep around a branch for work in progress that is always temporary and gets force reset to whatever you’re working on. (Remember a branch is just a pointer and nothing more, you can completely change what it points to without hurting anything, and the change is stored in the reflog, so there’s a undo button.) I think it is possible to make a branch & commit workflow that is both easier and safer than stash.
In case you weren’t aware, stash is not as safe as other git commands, it doesn’t have the same safety net and reflog support as a commit does. It’s relatively easy to drop stashes accidentally and lose them forever. I’ve seen people do this in production by not being careful when pulling while they have a dirty work tree. The man page for git stash mentions this fact:
“If you mistakenly drop or clear stash entries, they cannot be recovered through the normal safety mechanisms. However, you can try the following incantation to get a list of stash entries that are still in your repository, but not reachable any more:
”https://git-scm.com/docs/git-stash