News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by arcticbull on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:49PM (#25116146)
Lockdowns do 100% work, if you stay inside you literally cannot catch a respiratory illness. You stay inside for 3 weeks and it will literally end the respiratory illness unless there's another reservoir you've failed to account for.

Non-compliance however kneecaps the ability of lockdowns to be effective, leaving you in a worst-of-all-worlds situation with a damaged economy and a largely unaffected disease curve. I would say the better way to frame that is:

- "lockdowns only work if you actually take them seriously" (as evidenced by countries that did: NZ, TW, CN, AU -- look at their graphs [1], they work).

- and "lockdowns may not be necessary to achieve sufficient results."

[1] https://aatishb.com/covidtrends/?location=Australia&location...

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by xyzzyz on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:04PM (#25116339)
You stay inside for 3 weeks and it will literally end the respiratory illness unless there's another reservoir you've failed to account for.

In other words, the illness will die out, unless it doesn't. Here's some practical experience with this approach:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2130424/

An outbreak of common colds at an Antarctic base after seventeen weeks of complete isolation.

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by roca on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:26PM (#25116590)
More relevant practical experience: NZ's lockdown shows that we were able to eliminate COVID19 within the country. Six weeks of a pretty hard lockdown followed by six more weeks of gradual relaxing of restrictions.
Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by quicklyfrozen on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:51PM (#25116844)
I'm not sure there's any possible way to achieve a real lockdown in the US when half the population doesn't even believe in the severity of the virus. How would you enforce it?

And a strict lockdown would require most people to have enough supplies in place to last the few weeks, which is likely an impossible demand for our supply chain to meet, and also impossible for those who live paycheck to paycheck.

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by worker767424 on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:15PM (#25116465)
They are very effective, but a shared HVAC system could also infect an entire building, and it might not happen quickly enough for 3 weeks to be "safe."

They were effective in NZ, but NZ is still getting new cases, so it's remarkably hard to get 100%.

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by thisrod on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:12PM (#25118826)
> NZ is still getting new cases

In fairness, those are due to quarantine failures, which were anticipated and planned for.

Why would a region with one person per square kilometer plan to quarantine people in a crowded hotel in the centre of a crowded city, and respond to the inevitable outbreaks which potentially expose millions of people to the virus, when you could divert all the jets to Woomera and stick everyone in tents for 14 days? That's a question which those responsible are trying hard to ignore.

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by roca on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:22PM (#25116539)
Having zero cases all the time is remarkably hard but it's also not that important. A lockdown-to-elimination strategy is working well if you can keep driving the number down to zero with low restrictions in place. In NZ it is working well.
Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by roca on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:59PM (#25116274)
> "lockdowns may not be necessary to achieve reasonable results."

Even so, Sweden doesn't prove this. They have had lockdowns, e.g. severe limits on social gatherings. You can only say they haven't had lockdowns if you take the pedantic view that "it's not a lockdown if it's not legally enforced, even if everyone follows your rules".

Also, arguably the excess deaths in March/April (comparing to Nordic neighbours especially) and the surging cases now are not "reasonable results".

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by matz1 on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:59PM (#25116269)
>You stay inside for 3 weeks and it will literally end

Thats why it wouldn't work. You want everyone to stay inside for 3 weeks.

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by CrazyPyroLinux on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:02PM (#25116299)
And if we blast everyone to the moon, that'd theoretically fix it too. But if we're talking about actual realistic options, you can't lock down hard enough consistently enough for long enough across a wide enough swath of the planet for it to really work. And no, that isn't because some small amount of "selfish" people won't comply with such police-state dystopian policies - It's because there's a practical limit on how effective they can be.
Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by arcticbull on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:08PM (#25116385)
The graphs are very clear, there are examples of countries in which it worked great.

> "people won't comply with such police-state dystopian policies"

The "but muh freedom" argument is so tired. If folks had stayed in for a few weeks at the start, it would be substantially over now as evidenced by all the countries in which it's substantially over. Instead by going out like petulant children who won't be told no, we have a giant flaming disaster. That would be an example of 'disagree and commit.'

I'm open to the idea that a lockdown would work, and I'm also open to the idea it's not necessary because some subset of restriction is enough, or because we're willing to pay the cost of excess mortality during vaccine development -- the one argument I'm not open to is "but muh freedom."

I'm sorry that reality doesn't always map to the libertarian ideal. Sometimes you have to compromise temporarily for the greater good. For your own greater good. For a net gain in freedom.

[1] https://aatishb.com/covidtrends/?location=Australia&location...

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by matz1 on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:25PM (#25116578)
Not worth the risk/harm due to lockdown, at least for this virus.

I'm still open to the idea that a lockdown would work but not for this virus.

>For your own greater good. For a net gain in freedom

You mean for your greater good because it definitely not for my greater good.

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by arcticbull on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:29PM (#25116615)
Had we gotten it over and done with your freedom would have been materially improved over the subsequent months would it not? You're unhappy with this awful compromise, as everyone should be -- caused by a refusal to adhere to either opening the economy and paying the cost, or to a proper lockdown.

And you should be upset about it, I am, it's been an abject failure. We've compromised so much, but just not quite enough, in part because of the uneven distribution of compliance. That has led to huge cost for zero reward.

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by matz1 on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:54PM (#25116889)
>Had we gotten it over and done with your freedom would have been materially improved over the subsequent months would it not?

No, because we don't even need the lockdown in the first place. I'm not saying nothing should be done to about this virus, but if the answer of 'doing something about it' is lockdown then I can't support because the harm is just immense (compared to the risk of this virus).

Yes, I am upset at the government reaction to this virus.

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by couchand on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:47PM (#25119779)
The hospital around the corner from me had two freezer trucks parked outside for months because there wasn't enough room inside for the dead bodies piling up. The harm from this virus is very real, even if you are lucky enough to have so far avoided the worst of it personally.
Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by matz1 on Monday November 16, 2020 @11:45PM (#25120337)
I didn't say the harm from the virus is not real. I said the harm from lockdown is more than the harm from virus.
Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by arcticbull on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @02:16PM (#25128290)
[citation needed], but of course would be welcome.
Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by couchand on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @08:28AM (#25123470)
It's not.
Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by CrazyPyroLinux on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:28PM (#25116609)
Read my comment more carefully before straw manning my argument. I specifically said: > And no, that isn't because some small amount of "selfish" people Perhaps that distracted you, but my point was that even if everyone intended to comply, there are practical limits to that compliance in practice.

Although I will say, if "freedom" is the "one argument [you are] not open to" I don't think you have the moral high ground.

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by arcticbull on Monday November 16, 2020 @03:49PM (#25116828)
There are practical limits to compliance, and the countries that have successfully knocked the case counts to single digit daily indicate it is not necessary to breech those limits to achieve material results.

> Although I will say, if "freedom" is the "one argument [you are] not open to" I don't think you have the moral high ground.

We'll have to disagree on this one. "You can't make me" isn't going to win you any arguments at the supermarket with your mom, it's not going to win you any arguments at home with your spouse, it's not going to win you any arguments at work, and it sure as heck isn't going to win you any arguments in public health policy.

Again, I'm open to the idea they may not be necessary to achieve meaningful results, however that is a conversation that can be had without invoking the toddler clause.

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by CrazyPyroLinux on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:16PM (#25117080)
> We'll have to disagree on this one.

Yes we will, since you are arguing in bad faith. I can smell the condescension from here. I never said "you can't make me" but YOU said "petulant children who won't be told no" and "toddler clause" and "muh freedom"

THAT is the type of rhetoric that "isn't going to win you any arguments at the supermarket with your mom"

Re:No excess deaths in Sweden compared to the last ten years by arcticbull on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:50PM (#25118110)
Totally fair.