News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube-dl's repository has been restored by rectang on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:06AM (#25112500)
> Does copyright law end with HEAD on master?

With regards to copyright law and "distribution", there's no distinction. The tests are still being "distributed", just from a different URL. If youtube-dl was in violation before, they still are now.

This is a confusing result. I would not expect any copyright litigant to sacrifice legal advantage for the sake of an adversary's convenience in maintaining complete version control history.

Could there possibly have been a miscommunication over what "remove the tests" meant? Or an offer of compromise outside of legal necessity? Or a bad-faith fulfillment of a promise to "remove the tests"?

Re:YouTube-dl's repository has been restored by cosmojg on Monday November 16, 2020 @11:37AM (#25113677)
Does the fact that the RIAA is packed with stodgy, old corporate lawyers who most likely lack even superficial understanding of the term "version control" lack appropriate explanatory power?
Re:YouTube-dl's repository has been restored by rectang on Monday November 16, 2020 @11:46AM (#25113817)
Such "stodgy, old corporate lawyers" are going to become extremely antagonized should they discover that somebody pulled a fast one on them. All you'd have to do is open a web browser and click around to show them that the tests were still accessible.

So what's confusing is the youtube-dl side's strategy. Are they really trying to pull a fast one? That would be incredibly unwise, so I doubt it.

Re:YouTube-dl's repository has been restored by kzrdude on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @05:41AM (#25122183)
Everything just points to the dmca takedown request being treated as if it was invalid; the repository was restored more quickly than needed and without any real changes.