Statistically, the long-term damages attributable to total nuclear fuel chains are lower than those of the total natural gas fuel chain.
Every now and then, I see a tech news article about a new breakthrough in solar that should be ready for the market in the mythical "3-5 years" timeframe, then I never hear about it again. I'd be very happy to see some evidence that there's real, marketable progress being made right now that isn't marginal improvements to existing inefficient and expensive technology.
Two more words: electric car.
In the next 30 years a significant fraction of the transportation and other oil-powered infrastructure is going to get connected to the power grid. Solar and wind can barely make a dent in current demand with current technology.
When electric cars get cheap, power demand will explode.
Doing this would cool the earth by about the same amount as moving it ~12.5% further away from the sun.
Solar is not a viable long-term solution.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earth%27s_energy_budget#Incomin...
I'm getting 5.510^24 J/yr ~= 5,500,000 EJ/yr (all wavelenghts).
This doesn't make Nuclear energy a smart choice, just because it is better than an even worse choice. We need to stop limiting our view to these two technologies, and start funding crazier energy options that could be cleaner, safer and smarter for the long run.
Currently solar power is getting much cheaper and more practical. Same thing with wind power. We also have a natural gas which recently has been getting cheaper as large new discoveries are being made.
Natural gas is still a fossil fuel but it is much much cleaner than coal both in terms of health pollutants and in terms of CO2. There are some issues with natural gas extraction, but even if the various environmentally damaging methods of mining the stuff get banned as they should, we still have plenty of natural gas from new discoveries to last us for the foreseeable future.
Thus, we can use natural gas while solar and wind catch up price wise, which will happen sooner than we think. Solar especially is improving faster than anyone thought. Then we can still use natural gas for occasions where solar and wind aren't working.
So the coal/nuclear argument is a false dichotomy. We can have neither. Of course we should run the current nuclear plants until the end of their lives, but there is no reason to build new ones unless some revolutionary technology that makes everything much safer emerges. I would say the only new nuclear plants we should build are ones that burn the waste of the old ones, because those would technically make things safer by removing waste.