News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by sova on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:11PM (#25104883)
We went from abacus to digital circuit painstakingly over thousands of years and you're using a compute-er with a screen to post this comment. There's nothing wrong with paper except its extreme inefficiency in the human realm. We could have audit-able ballots and public/private keys to check that our ballots have been counted and tabulated correctly. Is it the case, perhaps, that ballots are supposed to be "private" and therefore we have "private" software count them?
Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by heavyset_go on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:16PM (#25104936)
> We could have audit-able ballots and public/private keys to check that our ballots have been counted and tabulated correctly.

With electronic voting, the bar for being able to validate vote counts is raised to requiring computer experts who understand public-key encryption.

With paper ballots, anyone who can count is able to validate votes.

Electronic voting would be prime for obfuscated attempts at influencing elections because only a handful of people would be able to verify that the machines counted votes correctly.

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by chrisseaton on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:12PM (#25104893)
> There's nothing wrong with paper except its extreme inefficiency in the human realm.

They aren't inefficient. In the UK (paper ballots) an accurate estimate is available when the polls close, and a certain result is available within a few hours before next morning. This is much faster than US voting machines.

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by takeda on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:38PM (#25105136)
Don't know about UK, but I suspect it is because they start counting as soon as they receive them.

In US there were some laws that counting couldn't start before polls are closed. Despite mail in ballots arriving a month earlier. In some places they weren't even allowed to prepare them for counting (like verifying signatures and removing ballots from envelopes).

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by chrisseaton on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:39PM (#25105142)
The UK does not start counting until polls are closed. They count all ballots - both in-person and mail-in - within a few hours. They have a lot of people in gyms and just go through them quickly.
Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by creato on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:52PM (#25105263)
The states that had long delayed results were due to being close, and accepting mail in ballots long after polls closed. It's not a matter of counting speed.
Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by chrisseaton on Sunday November 15, 2020 @05:04PM (#25105355)
The UK does recounts in hours, not weeks.
Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by godelski on Sunday November 15, 2020 @06:06PM (#25105841)
This election is an anomaly and should not be considered the norm. But there's also some confusion where winners get announced before the total counting is done. They are just announced when there is believed to be statistical certainty. A nation wide (full) recount is not happening in a few hours and if it was I would expect it to have a decent error margin. The UK also doesn't have as many options on the ballots as the US you have president, house, senate, judges, reps, measures, state constitution amendments, etc. You can't make a one to one comparison.
Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by treis on Sunday November 15, 2020 @05:19PM (#25105471)
Aren't UK elections generally just for your individual MPs? That's different than the US where you will have numerous races and ballot issues during the same election. For example, I voted for President, 2 senators, a congressman, probably a dozen state & local officials, and three state constitutional amendments.
Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by chrisseaton on Sunday November 15, 2020 @05:20PM (#25105488)
Usually for MPs and councillors, but yes probably less than what you vote for. But couldn't you count at least president within hours? And then go back on a priority schedule? Doesn't seem to need computers.
Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by rootusrootus on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:41PM (#25105168)
> In US there were some laws that counting couldn't start before polls are closed.

This is a good time to remind everyone that in the U.S. there are many different voting jurisdictions, and at the very least 50 different sets of rules. Some similar, some not. So it's difficult to generalize, some places count early, some not, some allow late arrivals, some not, etc.

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by c0llision on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:29PM (#25105065)
True, but:

1. You didn't have to count 151 million votes in the UK election

2. You didn't have to wait a few days for mail-in ballots that were delayed in transit to arrive

3. You didn't have to do this in the middle of a global pandemic that required poll workers to stay 6 feet apart

Generally the US election results can be predicted the same day, this year had additional challenges due to extremely high turn-out, high use of mail-in ballots, and limited number of pool workers due to pandemic.

In my opinion, elections should be done using paper ballots, and those ballots are counted using electronic tabulation machines. After a batch of ballots are counted, a random sample of them are selected and manually counted. Should the results match, then you can have a high certainty of the accuracy of the count. Electronic tabulation machines are actually more accurate than hand-counting, and by hand counting again, you reduce the risk of the machines making "mistakes" due to technical glitches or malicious backdoors etc.

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by brigandish on Sunday November 15, 2020 @06:01PM (#25105820)
There were 32,014,110 in the last UK general election, which is one fifth of the US total, but then the population is also (roughly) one fifth of the US’.
Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by rootusrootus on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:40PM (#25105155)
> This is much faster than US voting machines.

That's actually pretty much on par for much of the U.S. We have paper ballots and results mostly finished before the next morning. There are stragglers, of course, for good reasons, but you don't really hear much about those unless they are possibly going to decide the election, like this year.

And then of course 2020 is it's own special kind of fun, not typical of any other year.

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by jcranmer on Sunday November 15, 2020 @05:25PM (#25105534)
Honest question here: how many races and questions do you vote on at once in the UK?

This year, my ballot had about a dozen individual races (including two state referendums and an advisory question) to vote on, and this is probably about or below the US median ballot complexity each presidential election.

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by chrisseaton on Sunday November 15, 2020 @05:50PM (#25105727)
I'm sure you have more on your ballot than us.

But can you not return a presidential result in the first few hours, and then go back in priority order?

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by throwaway2245 on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:32PM (#25105082)
11 states including Alaska, Arizona, Nevada, and Michigan have a larger land area than the UK.

[Edited to add: 46 states have a lower population density than the UK, adding further logistical consideration]

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by chrisseaton on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:33PM (#25105089)
I don't understand what impact you think this makes?

If each community counts their votes... why does it matter how large an area they collectively cover?

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by brudgers on Sunday November 15, 2020 @07:06PM (#25106312)
The US has 21 counties that are larger than Wales. 50 counties larger than Northern Ireland. Not states, counties. And Alaska doesn’t have counties so it’s not dominating the results.

The US is vast. The political geography is different because the physical geography is different.

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by throwaway2245 on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:41PM (#25105163)
It already has an impact within the UK.

St Ives constituency in the UK is generally the last to declare, presumably because the island populations are so small and remote it's considered unsafe for them to individually count and report the results for collation, for multiple potential reasons (Gugh: 3 residents)

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by chrisseaton on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:43PM (#25105186)
And yet they have it done within a few hours.

Why is it about the US that means it takes a week... even with these machines which supposedly make it better?

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by throwaway2245 on Sunday November 15, 2020 @07:01PM (#25106262)
If you reject my claim that US has many-times more remote places than the UK, that need additional logistical consideration, a further reason is that the US election has no particular hurry.

If your count in the UK doesn't finish for a week, the parliamentary session opens, and you don't have local representation in parliament. There's an immediate procedural consequence that disadvantages the local area and may result in concentrated unrest.

If your count in the US doesn't finish, the relevant [Congressional] term doesn't start until January 3rd, 2021. As such, there's no immediately comparable procedural consequence.

The Electoral College doesn't cast its votes until December 14th.

The Supreme Court won't get involved, to hurry you up, until December 8th.

Correctly postmarked ballots will (in some states) still be counted if they arrive late, up to November 23rd.

Today is still November 15th. In theory, not all the votes have even arrived to be counted yet.

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by jrumbut on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:19PM (#25104969)
Inefficiency is a feature, having every state and every county slightly different makes systemic fraud very difficult.

All these phishing schemes that are extremely effective with IT workers and other security conscious people. I say just keep elections analog for the time being. Perhaps someday the technology will be mature, well understood, and distributed far enough to work but I don't see it happening this decade.

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by sova on Sunday November 15, 2020 @06:00PM (#25105814)
That's an interesting point because it effectively nullifies the argument for more nuanced voting mechanisms such as Score Voting. Since more nuanced voting would require a stronger reliance on vote tabulators. It is somewhat deflating that better voting methods must be discarded in favor of "inefficiency as a feature." I long for an upgrade to voting, but all these arguments _in favor of_ hand-counting-only make me think we are stuck with plurality voting for a long time.
Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by godelski on Sunday November 15, 2020 @06:12PM (#25105888)
> it effectively nullifies the argument for more nuanced voting mechanisms such as Score Voting.

I'm extremely confused by this statement. All the systems the parent is talking about still use plurality. Substituting in another voting method doesn't change the fact that each state works slightly differently (and really every county).

I'd also say that if this was your goal then you'd want something besides plurality. RCV/IRV would probably be good because it is highly inefficient because you have to do many different rounds whereas systems like plurality and condorcet (exception to STAR, which has 2 rounds) are single round methods.

I should mention Ireland and Australia does hand counting with IRV (Australia has had IRV for 100+ years). I don't think the hand counting is really a major factor, though I will still contend that ordinal systems are needlessly complicated when we have cardinal systems available to us (which also give higher fidelity).

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by sova on Sunday November 15, 2020 @10:11PM (#25107543)
IRV with hand-counting sounds nigh impossible, I have a hard time imagining how it is done. Are the multiple rounds done as multiple hand-counts?
Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by godelski on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:57AM (#25108564)
I remember seeing a video where they were showing the counting on an election night, but that was awhile ago. I looked for it again but the current situation is muddying the search results. But I can try to remember. What I remember is that it was a pretty messy process and they were marking ballots (I think with stickers to keep the ballots immutable). But yeah, generally it is chaotic. But clearly it was done because Australia didn't have computers in the early 1900's. At least to the best of my knowledge.

As for part more information Clay (who might be in this thread somewhere?) put out a pretty good video on voting methods and towards the end he shows a sample of an Oakland Mayoral result that used IRV[0] (around 15:20). It isn't too useful in isolation but I do encourage watching the whole thing because it is from someone who is a HN member and an expert on voting.

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HyBm_Hcu4DI

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by jrumbut on Sunday November 15, 2020 @06:10PM (#25105872)
I have a suspicion that a complex voting system (like, anything more complex than "most votes win") would spread greater confusion and distrust, that's just my pessimism.

I would be happy if we could have a national popular vote to choose the president, that reduces complexity. I'm wary of anything more, though I do like that there are now some experiments here and there with other systems.

Edit: I've recently come to the conclusion that the real value of elections is as a national show of force.

"1xx,000,000 of us are here and paying attention and expecting the government to respond to our interests and willing to do something about it"

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by naniwaduni on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:52AM (#25108531)
Use approval voting, which captures all the advantages of score voting at scale anyway and is dead simple to count.
Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by xur17 on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:26PM (#25105029)
> Inefficiency is a feature, having every state and every county slightly different makes systemic fraud very difficult.

I agree with this - in addition, it makes it a lot easier for everyone to understand the system, and therefore more likely to trust it.

Re:Ask HN: Why Isn't Open Source Voting Software Mandated? by Closi on Sunday November 15, 2020 @05:45PM (#25105695)
> makes it a lot easier for everyone to understand the system, and therefore more likely to trust it.

Is this the USA system we are talking about? Because a significant proportion don’t seem to understand or trust the system right now!