News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by bostonpete on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @11:36AM (#2510360)
People that coal kills have accepted the risk to the same extent that you or I have accepted the risk of nuclear. In many cases, they don't have practical alternative to working in the coal mines. So yes, they choose to work in the coal mines, much like most of us choose not to move as far away from nuclear plants as possible, but it's not really that much of a choice.
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by cal5k on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @11:31AM (#2510324)
So... you're saying that people who breathe in dangerous pollutants produced in goal plants had it coming?
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by swaits on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @12:05PM (#2510532)
I believe the point is that coal plants are understood to always pollute, whereas nuclear plants are promised to never pollute. Can you see where that distinction is important?
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by roel_v on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @12:15PM (#2510571)
Who has ever promised that nuclear plants will never pollute? That's a ludicrous statement to make, and it's almost as ludicrous to state that someone respectable has ever promised so.
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by swaits on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @04:52PM (#2511613)
Excuse me, but if a nuclear plant pollutes, specifically in the form of un-contained radiation, that's considered a failure, right?
Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by roel_v on Wednesday May 04, 2011 @05:21AM (#2513272)
Yes, what's your point?

Option 1: coal plant that, statistically and averaged over all plants, kills x amount of people every day of the year (through exhaust pollution, killed miners, etc.)

Option 2: nuclear plant that kills y amount of people, averaged the same; direct kills through accidents + indirect through increased cancer risks (discounted for natural occurrences of those cancers etc.)

When x > y, it's better to use nuclear. And y, despite the Fukushima fear mongering, is quite small.

The matter is not 'nuclear can fail, so we shouldn't use it'; the matter is 'which one has the lowest overall cost' (cost taking into account lives, health risks, economic risks etc); and then choosing that one.

Re:Bill Gates On Nuclear Energy: Compared To Coal, It Is Sti... by sigzero on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @12:12PM (#2510560)
I have never seen that second assertion.