News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by el_nahual on Saturday November 14, 2020 @04:58PM (#25096015)
I'm a foreigner that's lived in the US since college. Half of my friends and family are american and the rest foreign. There's a huge cultural difference between both sides' approach to wealth.

My american f&f (outside of silicon valley) think of wealth in terms of "saving for retirement." 401ks, tax strategies, etfs, stocks etc. It's very passive, probably "correct", and very unambitious.

The foreign side is totally different. They have very little interest in saving for retirement--they think in terms of investing in businesses. They don't buy etfs or stocks. They buy (small, then larger) businesses. It's very active and after age 40 or so takes up most of their time. The goal is to never retire, but rather to build a series of cash producing entities for ever.

Part of this is certainly cultural. In lots of the world, being a boss is higher status that being an *employee", regardless of the actual income each activity generates. The owner of a business with 200k in revenue is higher status than a McKinsey employee with a 500k salary.

This cultural difference is reflected in a desire to escape "wages" as soon as possible, not necessarily "save for retirement".

Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by akiselev on Saturday November 14, 2020 @05:22PM (#25096224)
> This cultural difference is reflected in a desire to escape "wages" as soon as possible, not necessarily "save for retirement".

I don't think it has to do with that necessarily (at least in my cohort), it's just that many immigrants come from nations who haven't had stability in their financial systems, if they even had one to begin with. A business has tangible roots in a community and can generate revenue when there's a monetary collapse, which is much easier for someone to trust if they haven't grown up in a stable economy. My old country doesn't even have 30 year mortgages, for example. If it did, mortgages expiring now would have been signed right as the iron curtain was coming down, which drastically changed the Eastern bloc's financial systems almost over night.

Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by refurb on Sunday November 15, 2020 @01:07AM (#25098714)
This isn't that unusual and is sometimes driven by available opportunities. If you live in a developing economy, the number of $500k equivalent jobs is likely not high, and at least for the countries I've visited, they are often roles at multi-nationals with foreigners at the top (and not all that accessible to locals).

Similarly, your potential investments for retirement savings can be quite limited. We're quite spoiled in the west to have massive stock markets with tens of thousands of stable, profitable companies. And a regulatory framework which means the chance you buy a stock and find out the entire company is a fraud is relatively low. I've heard from folks in some developing countries that they'd never put money in their own stock market - the chance of losing everything is way too high.

For developing countries, you often have a young, expanding population, and 7% GDP growth in one year wouldn't be seen as abnormal. Small businesses become a great way to get in on the growth (the market is often highly fragmented, so competition isn't that fierce) and businesses are a much more accessible way to wealth than any corporate job. The other avenue I've seen is real estate. In the SE Asian countries I've been in (the ones growing quickly), real estate is even more of a ticket to wealth than in the US. Seems like they can never build enough and in the big cities, prices aren't that different than non-coastal US ($100k+ USD), which is shocking considering the median salary is 1/10th that of the US.

Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by darkerside on Saturday November 14, 2020 @05:35PM (#25096311)
> The owner of a business with 200k in revenue is higher status than a McKinsey employee with a 500k salary.

What makes you say that?

Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by el_nahual on Saturday November 14, 2020 @06:28PM (#25096646)
Status is weird like that. Different cultures assign status differently. In many parts of the world--certainly in LatAm--status is about power and independence more than it is about money.
Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by darkerside on Saturday November 14, 2020 @09:30PM (#25097694)
If it wasn't clear, I'm not disagreeing, I'm looking for examples, or other reasons for that belief

Edit: The note I think about it, the more I'm inclined to disagree after all. A $500K McKinsey employee is not an entry level consultant. They are likely leading a large team and working regularly with C-level executives at enterprise businesses. They are going to have presence and gravitas because credibility is a huge part of their job.

What kind of business does $200K in revenue per year? It's very likely to be a sole proprietorship, maybe 1-2 employees at most.

I realize that there may be cultures and subcultures that truly believe the independence of the business owner makes them more respectable (although I personally believe that independence is a bit of an illusion), but I think more people would subconsciously assign a higher status to the first person and that it probably wouldn't be close.

Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by yeetman21 on Saturday November 14, 2020 @05:51PM (#25096416)
He can sell the business or still run it in retirement, McKinsey employee works 25 hours a day and is a slave to his boss
Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by icedchai on Saturday November 14, 2020 @10:20PM (#25097935)
A small business like that is likely very, very dependent on its owner. The owner may be a slave to his customers. The employee can just walk away.
Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by darkerside on Saturday November 14, 2020 @10:46PM (#25098069)
Exactly. You don't make money without having a boss (or many bosses).
Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by marketgod on Sunday November 15, 2020 @09:49AM (#25101594)
You can fire customers easier than quitting jobs. I fire customers daily. If you are reliant on 1 customer then it's not a business, it's a hobby.

Edit: Also you can be ethical.

Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by darkerside on Sunday November 15, 2020 @09:34PM (#25107321)
This is more a function of your successfulness and competence than whether you happen to have an incorporated business wrapping your daily operations.

A successful and competent employee has built relationships with colleagues, supervisors, and reports. He knows them, and they know him. He won't be asked to subjugate his principles to the company in an inappropriate way, in part because others know that he will go above and beyond within his principles to do well for the company.

For a business owner, the exact same thing, just replace colleagues et al with customers, suppliers, shareholders, and other partners.

On the other hand, a weak business and/or business owner will be very vulnerable to principle-based compromise. Out of the need to keep customers, suppliers, et al happy, he is subject to whim and every demand. Walking away from his business means the collapse of his reputation, failing his employees, and failing his family. He is no more free than your average entry level employee.

Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by marketgod on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:25PM (#25119671)
>He won't be asked to subjugate his principles to the company in an inappropriate way, in part because others know that he will go above and beyond within his principles to do well for the company.

I respectfully disagree. Your team may not, your direct reports won't and your management hierarchy may not, however, your business will. If you have certain principles such as support for LBGTQ+, anti-military contracts, or a conservative in tech for example, and your company signs a contract to work with another organization that doesn't care about the cause or are completely against it, what happens? I know CEO's who can't fire bad clients because they don't own their own company.

>Walking away from his business means the collapse of his reputation, failing his employees, and failing his family.

Walking away from bad business can make you so much money it's hard to imagine. I've had conversations about doing business with shady people, which resulted in me making a deal with the person who had the same experience with the other individual.

>On the other hand, a weak business and/or business owner will be very vulnerable to principle-based compromise.

Growing pains, but an employee who is competent or incompetent will face the same dilemma because of what I suggested earlier.

I call it being a slave earlier, to intentionally raise alarm. I don't know of a way to define it but you don't have to go to sleep at night thinking, well, I didn't like that decision and now I need to change my entire life or deal with it. I.e. find a new job, change my commute, change my schedule, acquaint yourself with a new environment, meet new people and so on. An owner, is doing this on a daily basis already.

Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by darkerside on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:55PM (#25119821)
> If you have certain principles such as support for LBGTQ+, anti-military contracts, or a conservative in tech for example, and your company signs a contract to work with another organization that doesn't care about the cause or are completely against it, what happens?

I guess things are changing, but historically refusing to serve customers based on political differences would be considered intolerant. You can disagree with someone without refusing them service. I don't see any ethical dilemmas in serving someone you disagree with. You are free to disagree with that principle.

For any business owner, making a decision to walk away from business on grounds of political disagreement is a huge luxury. I don't think it's commonly exercised, and for good reason, imo. This is very different from walking away from a "bad customer", one who may cost you money over the long run while sapping your soul. Empowered employees also feel capable of walking away from these customers because they understand the business so well that they see the issues coming, and they've earned to decision making respect for their choices to have weight.

> Growing pains, but an employee who is competent or incompetent will face the same dilemma because of what I suggested earlier.

This is exactly what I'm saying. The two are more similar than I think most people make them out to be. You will have differences in freedom, but those are often determined by your competence and success, more so than whether you have a business license.

The way you talk about a business owner sleeping well at night makes me wonder if you know any. Owning a business is extremely stressful. The buck stops with you, and while in theory you are free, your entire business depends on your decisions. You think it's hard to change jobs? How hard do you think it is to move on from a failed business? In a capitalist society, business owners are as much slaves as anyone else. The difference is, you take so much risk on that if you succeed, you end up making a return that does buy you a good deal of freedom. But that's not intrinsic to the business you own, and it is determined as much but what you need as what you have. It's a freedom derived from being a human being that has "enough".

Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by marketgod on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @02:10AM (#25120997)
>I guess things are changing, but historically refusing to serve customers based on political differences would be considered intolerant. You can disagree with someone without refusing them service. I don't see any ethical dilemmas in serving someone you disagree with. You are free to disagree with that principle.

Let's not separate a single example, the entire example list is as a whole, i.e. any of the situations listed are that to the person involved. Sure for you it doesn't, however, someone else will have a different opinion with respect to dealing with other political stripes. There are people who won't deal with other religions in this day and age.

>> Growing pains, but an employee who is competent or incompetent will face the same dilemma because of what I suggested earlier.

I typed this in a way it was not clear. The growing pains will heal. The competent and incompetent employees will always be slaves, their competence won't help them.

And yes, I sleep well.

Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by darkerside on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @06:13PM (#25131181)
And did you before you were established and successful?

Do you have experience where you succeeded as an employee without compromising on your principles as well?

Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by marketgod on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @07:04PM (#25131561)
No I was a wage slave. It is why I'm saying you can't succeed as an employee without compromising your principles. Even CEOs of Fortune 500s don't have the ability as they have a board to report to. Well except Zuck.
Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by darkerside on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @09:06AM (#25136851)
I think it's worth considering that, just because you didn't do it, does not mean it can't be done. Perhaps your personal growth was as big of a difference as the format of your labor relationship.
Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by marketgod on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @07:23PM (#25144632)
You can't. Nobody can. Not me, not you. I'm not sure you are understanding my point. If you work for someone you are their b * * * * *.

Yes you may grow but your values will be forced upon you subconsciously.

Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by marketgod on Sunday November 15, 2020 @12:26AM (#25098505)
Because one is a slave and the other is a man/woman.
Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by darkerside on Sunday November 15, 2020 @09:34PM (#25107324)
Disagree, see my other posts on this thread.
Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by skybrian on Saturday November 14, 2020 @05:16PM (#25096179)
Interesting. In what countries would you say that being a boss is a common ambition, and what kinds of businesses do you mean?
Re:Save like a pessimist, invest like an optimist by el_nahual on Saturday November 14, 2020 @06:26PM (#25096637)
In my experience, this is true in all of LatAm.