Re:Ask YC: Startup using Google App Engine?
by DocSavage on Saturday July 19, 2008 @05:04PM
(#250889)
Isn't there already a decent abstraction, namely the Datastore API (http://code.google.com/appengine/docs/datastore/)? Current apps are written against that API and it's not a stretch to see an opensource BigTable on EC2 with a Datastore API. (See appdrop.com for an even simpler datastore replacement.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Yes, that's BigTable specific. My point was that right now you have no option but to rewrite code if you need to move off App Engine and BigTable.
How is it not a stretch to see an open source BigTable on EC2? As far as I can tell BigTable has, up to this point, given Google a competitive edge. They are merely letting us come along for a ride and Amazon is a direct competitor in this market. Why in the world would they allow it to run on EC2?
Re:Ask YC: Startup using Google App Engine?
by DocSavage on Saturday July 19, 2008 @05:32PM
(#250907)
If you are coding to the Datastore API, you won't have to rewrite that code when moving to another provider who offers the Datastore API. AppDrop.com, for example, was a proof-of-concept that let you run apps on EC2 unchanged. He simply replaced the implementation below the datastore stubs.
Google may not open-source BigTable code, but as I mentioned above, there are a number of open-source projects that provide similar features. Any of these can run on EC2 together with the open-source AppEngine SDK.