The Westminster system is supposedly the basis for my country (Australia's) parliament but I believe we also have taken influences from other systems and have incorporated some things that aren't common anywhere else (like compulsory voting) our constitution comes from 1901.
I could be wrong, but I think the main difference Between US system and ours is how the leader is appointed. The US directly votes for president, where as here the winning party (Based on number of Lower House seats won) appoints the leader. Our Prime Minister is much more beholden to the party he belongs to where in US presidents gets to Veto stuff - I think.
In the US, laws are initiated in the House. If they pass the vote, they go to the Senate which must also vote to pass them. Finally, the President signs them into action or vetoes (which can be overridden by a 2/3 majority).
The Shay's Rebellion had a huge influence on the government design. The majority (all the farmers) agreed that they could vote to force the minority (the banks) to forgive their debts. Several of the earlier Federalist papers go over the many, many democracies that failed (usually for this very reason).
Voters actually elect people as state electors. Those electors come together to cast the actual vote for the president (with backups in case of election issues as this election is likely to require). The minimum number of electors gives slightly disproportionate power to less-populated states. Quite literally, the Constitution gives louder voices to minority areas.
We see this same idea in the Senate. States are equal members of the union no matter if they are large or small and the Senate gives them this power. Even the largest states (population-wise) can't just force through legislation to their exclusive benefit.
I wasn't taught that in history class. I was just taught the facts you described: that the compromise was made because it was the only way to get agreement at the convention on how the national legislature should be organized.
According to what parameter? Is there any objective manner in which bicameral parliaments fare better than unicameral ones?
Yeah, it's pretty weird.