Re:Effect of exercise training for five years on all cause m...
by zeteo on Thursday November 12, 2020 @05:07PM
(#25075776)
I think that's a valid point but it may not make a significant difference. Judging by the fact that the control group had a pretty decent drop-out rate it appears that the drop outs reverted to lower than average physical activity levels. I am playing devil's advocate here, but you can't rule out the hypothesis that trying a bit of HIIT convinced more people to take it easy at their age.
Re:Effect of exercise training for five years on all cause m...
by pytonslange on Friday November 13, 2020 @04:02PM
(#25087458)
I think I see the point you are making now. If HIIT to a greater degree prompts less fit participants to drop out than in the other groups, it might skew the results.
Not really sure in what direction though. If it had been a study on the effect of HIIT vs less intense training on cardiovascular fitness, this kind of dropout would bias the results in the direction of HIIT. I have no idea of what effect it would have when the variably of interest is mortality.
> but all participants were included for statistical analysis of the primary outcome (intention-to-treat approach).
I think this study looks rather solid.