News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Tell HN: Nextdns.io, a “privacy” company, leaks users' email and violates GDPR

Dearest HN community, I am reporting today a leakage of users' email addresses on the nextdns.io website.

When you sign up for an account, a POST request is made to a website called "intercom.io", it also sets cookies in your browser, a GDPR violation as no consent was provided. This can still be done as of the creation of this post, so you can see the violation of the GDPR for yourself.

If you study the request using dev tools, you will see the following is sent (among others):

URL: https://api-iam.intercom.io/messenger/web/ping

Data sent to their server:

user_data: {"email":"[email protected]"} - this is your email

page_title: Setup - My First Configuration - NextDNS

referer: https://my.nextdns.io/[url]/setup

When disclosing this issue, one of the founders sent me this URL:

https://www.reddit.com/r/nextdns/comments/jayc69/googleanalytics_scripts_running_on_the_homepage/

In the sticky reply, it suggests they've known about this leakage for at least a few weeks, if not longer.

Here's NextDNS privacy policy:

https://nextdns.io/privacy

"We do not (and will never) sell, license, sub-license or share any of the data submitted directly or indirectly by our users with any person or entity."

Lol. That was clearly a pack of lies then, wasn't it?

Here's intercom's privacy policy (note point 4 and who they share NextDNS users' emails with):

https://www.intercom.com/legal/privacy

That is all.

(P.S I did disclose this to them first, I did ask for a bounty, considered standard procedure for reporting such issues, and the co-founder didn't seem to understand how/why this is an issue, so I am letting the HN community decide instead).

( 2 comments | 14 points | on HN )
Re:Tell HN: Nextdns.io, a “privacy” company, leaks users' em... by el_dev_hell on Thursday November 12, 2020 @07:27PM (#25077235)
> 1. We do not (and will never) sell, license, sub-license or share any of the data submitted directly or indirectly by our users with any person or entity.

Oof..

Oddly, in the Reddit comment linked the company is acknowledging that they are "triggered" by Intercom, which I read as "yes, we know it's an issue and want to remove it ASAP". Super odd. They're basically admitting "yeah, the privacy policy is more a target than a policy".

Re:Tell HN: Nextdns.io, a “privacy” company, leaks users' em... by mattmanser on Thursday November 12, 2020 @07:42PM (#25077380)
Just to correct you, most of what your complaint is about does not violate GDPR. It's perfectly fine to set cookies under GDPR for technical reasons (e.g. sessions), it's also perfectly fine for them to use a 3rd party to deliver functionality. They can pass data to third parties for processing (delivering a chat app I assume).

In this particular case nextdns would be the data controller and intercom their data processor. That is not in violation of GDPR and is something covered by it.

I certainly don't think you deserve any sort of 'bug bounty' for this. At best you might have a case of emailing the nextdns information officer and asking them if intercom is selling your email address as intercom seem to claim they do.

However, Intercom seem to be very wrong about what they claim as their rights. But at the moment not a lot seems to being done about it for much worse violators so don't hold your breath that will change.

In the UK our version of the EFF (ORG) are trying to raise funds to force the ICO to prosecute big adtech that are in much more egregious breach of the GDPR.

https://action.openrightsgroup.org/help-us-protect-your-data...