There was an excellent program on how black boxes are made and tested on Discovery or NatGeo (can't remember which), but this was the next best thing I could find http://www.yourdiscovery.com/video/discovery-news-what-does-...
Of course, satellite comm requires various things like intact antennas pointing the right direction. On-board recording does not.
Perhaps my question is why aren't today's aircraft built with this sort of much more redundant system?
Aircraft already have redundant hydraulics, redundant data, flight controllers, fuel tanks, engines, wheels, pilots, .... Why not have "inexpensive" redundant data recorders?
This kind of technology is already deployed on a limited basis in a lot of commercial aircraft. An increasingly common business arrangement is for the airline to buy the aircraft but lease the engines (which are the parts requiring the most frequent maintenance). Rolls-Royce has a global infrastructure for telemetry data designed to shorten maintenance cycles and increase safety: see http://www.flightglobal.com/articles/2009/12/09/336006/rr-tr... and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aircraft_Communications_Address... for background.
Somehow I doubt that is what the poster meant and you are just building a straw-man argument to gain points.
Insulating, heating and protecting against shock should not be harder for a flash drive than insulating, heating and protecting against impact of a tape drive with lot of moving parts inside.
http://www51.honeywell.com/aero/common/documents/Flight_Data...
You shouldn't trust major media outlets with getting the technical details right...
However, everything installed on a plane needs to be certified for good reason, and unfortunately that makes even the simplest modifications expensive.
I don't understand now why in an aircraft strewn with various datalinks, there aren't a dozens or more inexpensive, lightweight easily findable flashdrives as datarecorders. You could place these at the wingtips, in the tail, in the landing gear, in all sorts of places that are known to survive.