Re:Understanding Statistical Power and Significance Testing
by pontus on Monday November 09, 2020 @03:01PM
(#25039196)
It's just a thought experiment meant to highlight a common fallacy in how people think about p-values.
Re:Understanding Statistical Power and Significance Testing
by throwaway2245 on Monday November 09, 2020 @04:23PM
(#25040102)
I find it fallacious to see this as a criticism of p-values.
If I wanted to identify whether a particular coin was the [most] biased out of 10^1000, flipping one coin 10 times isn't a reasonable setup for the experiment.
And, my conclusion to your hypothetical experiment would be: the person who told me that there was a 99.9...% chance this coin was fair was likely incorrect about that.
If you have 10^1000+1 coins, how did you accurately ascertain that exactly 1 coin was biased and the others were not?
And if you have been able to do that, well enough to state it as fact, why do you now need to do this statistical test?