You seem to believe that "huge value" is somehow decisive.
It isn't.
> that no system like this can prevail because of government
And you're dismissive of that factor because ?
Govts require taxes. You want a system that makes it trivial to avoid taxes. Guess which one is going to win?
The difference between filesharing and BC is that in the former the value is in the files, but BC is only valuable if you can trade them for something you value.
Govt can crack down at any point where bitcoin is convertible into something that they can affect.
For example, they can stop many biz from accepting bitcoin.
Sure, you'll probably be able to buy foreign porn with bitcoin, but ....
> Note how well the crack down on filesharing is going...
That's a very different problem.
Don't you agree with this?
Or do you believe that while useful, bitcoin won't be the system that prevails, or that no system like this can prevail because of government and/or special interests?
And on the issue of energy.. The sha256 generation is only to prove that you did invest time into it, and it is not a specific amount of time or energy either, but in relation to the total time spend by ALL miners during the past hours. I'm not saying that you don't know this, but it seems to be a common misconception.