Probably they were somewhat forced to do it for monetization purposes but it literally died overnight at my university when they started enforcing usernames.
it seems like it might be worth trying to build something similar now?
Re:Ask HN: What Happened to Yik Yak?
by el_dev_hell on Monday November 09, 2020 @09:45PM
(#25042371)
I'm still surprised no one has retried the Yik Yak strategy (anon, local, snapchat-esque points). I remember how popular it was on uni campuses in my country.
FWIW, it was never pseudonymous or anonymous. You could retrieve persistent identifiers for everyone, including phone numbers, GPS, etc. if you sniffed the request. They logged everything, verified non-VoIP numbers, and all.