News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by yokaze on Saturday November 07, 2020 @03:21AM (#25013799)
As far as I can see predominantly American Nazis. So the title may be pointing exactly that out.
Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by jariel on Saturday November 07, 2020 @03:30AM (#25013827)
Peter Thiel and the Weinstein Brothers are not Nazis.

Ironically, the very nature of the terminology validates concerns over 'cancel culture' which the podcaster & co. seem to lament. If 'one side' is worried about voices being suppressed, the 'other side' is labelling people 'Nazis' well you can see the problem.

I wonder what their reaction would be if Theil had an anti-Communist podcast called 'I don't speak Chinese' which lamented all their interlocutors and those with whom they don't agree as 'Communists'.

Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by kgarten on Saturday November 07, 2020 @03:48AM (#25013896)
Listen to the episode :) they don’t label Peter Thiel or the Weinsteins Nazis.
Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by p1necone on Saturday November 07, 2020 @03:33AM (#25013838)
If you read the description for the episode, they are not claiming that he's a Nazi. Podcasts don't have to stick exactly to the literal meaning of their titles 100% of the time.

(Also surely you recognize the irony in this kind of nitpicking of someone elses speech while simultaneously bringing up free speech.)

Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by jariel on Saturday November 07, 2020 @03:48AM (#25013894)
I read the title, listened for a bit to it, and some of their other podcasts.

The very nature of the podcast is to discuss 'Fascism' and I find including Thiel/Weinstein on the 'target list of Nazi-like people' though 'technically not Nazis' is intellectually offensive, and really defeating the purpose.

I don't care about Thiel, Weinstein, Jordan Peterson, Joe Rogan etc. or any of these people really but it's troubling when people try to suppress them or try to marginalize them as 'extremists'. There's absolutely nothing these guys are onto that should be remotely problematic in terms of civil discussion.

Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by kgarten on Saturday November 07, 2020 @03:54AM (#25013918)
Have you listend to the second episode? I know it’s a long one and with quite some rambling https://idontspeakgerman.libsyn.com/62-eric-weinstein-part-2...

At the end the elude to why they did the podcast episodes... check the last YouTube link of Eric .. that video is dangerous and stupid.

Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by jariel on Saturday November 07, 2020 @04:12AM (#25013996)
Is is the 'last link' [1] that you are referring to?

If it is, and you think this is 'dangerous' in any way I'm going to have to more than disagree, and suggest that any material issue over this video is probably a hint of something much more concerning. I really hope that wasn't the video you were referring to because I can't fathom any remotely reasonable person saying such a thing about it.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ETcq7qqPhow

'Some Thoughts on Wokeness and Shame in light of events.'

Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by kgarten on Saturday November 07, 2020 @06:00AM (#25014389)
He compares the breaking of glass by protestors to the Kristallnacht.

You don’t think that’s stupid or dangerous?

Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by neilsense on Saturday November 07, 2020 @04:48AM (#25014124)
There is no such thing as a 'dangerous' YouTube link. People have the option to make their own minds up and listen to opposing viewpoints.

I realise that a large chunk of HN are champagne socialists, but it would be great if they valued freedom of speech instead of starting to curb it.

Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by kgarten on Saturday November 07, 2020 @06:09AM (#25014423)
You don’t think comparing the breaking of some glass by BLM protesters to the Kristallnacht is stupid?

Dangerous I added because he has a following and I think if somebody believes him that Kristallnacht is happening right now, they might do sth. stupid.

I’m all for free speech, yet if you say stupid stuff, you can get called out for. I can call something stupid and dangerous and I don’t want to censor anything of it.

Listen to the 2 podcasts about Eric. I find them quite well sourced. If there’s anything wrong about their assertions (meaning the “I don’t talk German” podcasters) I think they are happy to hear from you.

Me too, btw. I’m open to discussion and would not want to hinder free speech.

Comparing BLM to the Nazis is pretty stupid, imho. Yet maybe I’m wrong ;)

Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by neilsense on Saturday November 07, 2020 @11:51AM (#25016199)
I think it's ultimately stupid and easily countered with dialogue and fact. Similar to the other stupid arguments such as Trump is akin to Hitler or is a facist in any true sense of the word.

I'd always rather have dialogue than bans. Though maybe that's the European in me.

Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by jariel on Saturday November 07, 2020 @02:35PM (#25018151)
You are decontextualizing the situation.

First - he's a Jew, literally with family members who died in the Holocaust - so he can make some comments about Kristallnacht.

Second - It's a some remarks while having an evening walk - this is not broadcast TV, a publication, some giant thing. It's an intimate conversation with some other nerds.

Third - parts of the 'equality' movement are violent, totalitarian, unwilling to compromise, breaking many laws, forcing their ideology onto all sorts of people without subtlety and without factual basis. is inflamed and supported by the press and academia,

The fact anyone would call this 'dangerous' - so 'dangerous' as to have him on a Podcast about Nazis is scary.

Re:Eric Weinstein Part 1 -the secret seminar by kgarten on Saturday November 07, 2020 @05:57PM (#25020522)
I’m German, some of my ancestors were In the Nazi party, some resisted.

Comparing BLM to the Kristallnacht is stupid and dangerous, from a Jew or from anybody else. He is insinuating with that comparison that

1. BLM is just some kind of pretext for totalitarianism

2. authorities are standing back and let them riot. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kristallnacht

I don't think it's his intention, yet can you see how this is dangerous? He gives militias a reason to go out and "defend" themselves against the authorities who are in on it (like during the Kristallnacht as this was state sanctioned) like the group that wanted to kidnapp Gov. Whitmer or the shooter who killed people in Kenosha.

2nd an intimate conversation with 180k views (more than some TV programs)

3rd some might be. Yet, if totalitarian fascists are coming, count me stupid I would hope for help from the Anarchists and Antifa action. Can you give examples? (FBI sees right wing terrorism a much bigger threat).

They (I don't speak German folks) give quite some context why they talk about him, why his views are problematic (they also say that he is not even close on being a nazi or related to them ... don’t know why it is scary). You can engage with their arguments if you want (yet you did not so far)