While I agree, the point isn't really moot since the server admin can come up with a host of rationalizations for it either way :P
Also no, you don't need an scp on the remote side.
I guess the rationalizations will change once scp (the protocol) is well and truly dead won't they?
You do need scp on the remote side. Try it yourself.
The point is moot though because disabling the sftp subsystem yet granting people shell access is backwards.