The trustee actually sold bitcoins during the 2017 run up in price and secured enough funds to pay off the cash value of the bankrupcy.
Sure, I don't expect MtGox to be able to make everyone whole. I just don't think it's accurate to say they're doing so by giving them their 2014 dollar equivalents.
All I'm saying is if you compare a hypothetical scenario where the bitcoin was distributed to creditors in 2014 to the hypothetical scenario where they receive it today, it's practically certain that creditors' aggregate wealth is astronomically higher in the latter scenario, because very few would have held the bitcoin long enough or sold at the right time to realize all of the 15x+ appreciation that has happened in that time.
I'm ignorant about this. Would they not have been able to be sold because there's some kind of master list of coins related to criminal activity, and exchanges blacklist them? Or would buyers somehow know specifically which coins they'd be buying and their provenance?
My guess is that almost all exchanges would flag any account that deposited coins from a list of known tainted addresses like this one, and either immediately freeze it or prevent withdrawals. And any exchange that didn't do it automatically would do it manually after it hit the news.
May I ask why? (Genuine, not a crypto expert). Do exchanges by default trace any bitcoins back and see if they were connected with illegality? Is there a list of tainted bitcoin addresses that are effectively worthless?
This is of course similar to the situation with conventional currencies. Banks will refuse to open an account if they suspect the money you're depositing is laundered. Bitcoin just makes this process far more amenable to automation, since detecting a history of laundering becomes a graph analysis problem.
I'm not sure why the bitcoin price has gone up in response to this news, because it means more supply is coming to the market soonish. These coins might have been presumed lost before. Certainly they would not have been able to be sold on any legitimate exchange. Now they will be washed clean and enter the markets.
On the other hand, a billion dollar bitcoin auction from the US government will generate some publicity, and publicity definitely drives the Bitcoin price up. We'll see which effect dominates.
There's another billion+ hoard of bitcoins which has the potential to be released to the markets in the next year or two, which is the MtGox reserves. Crazy story: MtGox went bankrupt after losing a bunch of bitcoins in hacks, but during the years-long bankruptcy proceedings the bitcoins they have left have been frozen, and their value has gone up so much that they could exit bankruptcy and pay all their debts many times over. But it's unclear what the bankruptcy court will ultimately allow them to do.
If the MtGox bitcoins are released to their many thousands of creditors (MtGox customers who had balances at the time of collapse), I expect a crash in the bitcoin price as many will choose to sell at the same time. This is different from the government bitcoin auctions, where there are only a few winners who probably don't plan to sell right away.