Re:Masks could save 130k American lives from COVID19 by March
by mindslight on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @11:36AM
(#24981167)
A quick search says that Sweden still has a growing number of new covid cases. So no, it does not look like they have achieved herd immunity.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Masks could save 130k American lives from COVID19 by March
by ezekg on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @11:43AM
(#24981255)
Herd immunity will likely never equal zero cases... the point is to prioritize herd immunity in the low-risk populace for the sake of the high-risk.
Re:Masks could save 130k American lives from COVID19 by March
by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:03PM
(#24981466)
But herd immunity should not equal a rising number of cases, which is what mindslight said. Your reply therefore doesn't actually answer the parent's claim.
Re:Masks could save 130k American lives from COVID19 by March
by ezekg on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:06PM
(#24981498)
You're right -- I should have said "on their way to real herd-immunity." Their death rate is what you should be watching, not cases.
Re:Masks could save 130k American lives from COVID19 by March
by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @03:21PM
(#24983552)
Why the death rate? If people are getting new cases, doesn't that mean that they weren't immune? And if the number of new cases is rising, doesn't that mean that the herd isn't immune?
I mean, yes, ultimately we care about deaths. But why do you think that deaths are the measure of herd immunity?
Re:Masks could save 130k American lives from COVID19 by March
by mindslight on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @11:58AM
(#24981416)
That's a nice hypothesis, but until it has been tested, that's what it remains. If Sweden is testing it that's nice for everyone else, but there's no need to run the experiment multiple times in parallel.
It's amazing to me that people so purportedly pro-freedom eagerly want the government to perform a public health experiment on the entire country. That's quite totalitarian if you ask me.
BTW by saying that mask wearing is opposed to herd immunity, you are tacitly agreeing that masks work to slow the spread.
Re:Masks could save 130k American lives from COVID19 by March
by ezekg on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @12:05PM
(#24981495)
How is me calling for less government totalitarian?
Re:Masks could save 130k American lives from COVID19 by March
by mindslight on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @01:19PM
(#24982343)
Deciding to run a large scale experiment of whether herd immunity is a worthwhile strategy for a novel disease is itself a top-down decision. It's not less government per se, just different government action.