Because as economically inefficient as a corporate income tax is, without it you would create an enormous incentive for individuals to incorporate, filter all their income through the corporation, have the corporation pay all their expenses as business expenses, purchase their assets for them as business assets, and compensate them in the form of loans which never get paid back. Yes, you could write the law in such a way as to prohibit this and spend a fortune on enforcement, but ultimately it would fail against such incentives.
Expensing anything is difficult as it must be solely for the business purposes and not personal use.
For example, you cannot generally expense food, clothes, housing, education etc. (You can probably expense an insignificant part of that though under some circumstances.) It’s not possible to take loans for extended periods of time without them actually counting as income for individuals (and being subject to income tax).
If you were to make the case the healthy, educated employees could be compensated through their wages, then that still leaves infrastructure, externalities and the legal system.
While you could privatise infrastructure, I think it would be a bad idea. It could lead to shady schemes where a corporation "taxes" its employees on the toll road leading up to the building. Considering historical examples like company stores, I'm not sure we could rule that scenario out. Also, where does infrastructure stop and what does it include? The last miles of telecoms, power, water and other utilities or more?
As to the legal system, it seems self-evident we don't want that privatised. Do you disagree?
On the topic of externalities: I suppose it's feasible to create new taxes specifically for what are now considered externalities, so corporations pay for them: pollution, carbon footprint, burnouts/boreouts, etc. Would you be in favour of those?
The human shareholders and human staff benefit (and profit) from those things, and there are already mechanisms in place to tax those human beings, either as shareholders or as staff with ordinary income.
Are you sure about that? Corporations cannot act (they have no hands, and no brains), and thus they cannot break the law. It also is relatively difficult to throw a corporation in jail for a criminal violation.
Even a much more informal association of people, a "criminal conspiracy", cannot be criminally charged as a single abstracted entity: the individuals who performed that conspiracy must be charged.
[1] http://www.stephankinsella.com/paf-podcast/kol-026-freedomai...
- There's only a single loophole: People who use their business to pay for personal expenses. They are easy to catch, and the simplicity of the tax scheme allows collectors to focus on this one loophole.
- It's simple to collect: Ask all the banks for everyone's statement, and apply a percentage to their calendar year's income. You could even deduct tax when people deposit money.
- It's simple to forecast and calculate: Everyone knows how much tax they owe, and knows how much tax they will owe.
- It's progressive: The more people make the more they pay. Property tax, sales tax, gas tax, etc. all disproportionately affect people with less money.
How is that part crazy? It isn't ideal certainly but the same thing held for farmers, fishermen, and tradesmen back when it was cottage industry. That is fundamentally a result of representative government and them being able to vote. Everybody has interests of some sort.
On the other hand, is the status quo ok? Are we getting something out of companies having to do these specific activities to deduct?
Not totally true. Interest free loan to the owner or his mother in law. Company buys a house / car / jet owner can use. Company buys consultancy services from the owners other company based in the Bahamas etc
All the money the corporation takes in ultimately gets spent on operating expenses, or is profit that is then distributed to shareholders who then owe taxes on that income.
If it’s annoying and counter intuitive that corporations are in some legal senses considered people, it is even more confusing that they pay taxes.
This sets up a crazy situation where employees of the corporations start lobbying and messing with policy and regulations so it favors the organization.
Seems like bad piled on top of bad. Increasing the tax rate on investment income is basically the same thing as taxing corporations, but would remove all these perverse incentives.