News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by wycy on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:50PM (#24972353)
The concern is less that Roe v Wade will be overturned outright so much as it will be de facto overturned by death by a thousand cuts. Dozens of abortion-rights cases are heading toward the Supreme Court, and Mississippi's attempt to pass a 15-week abortion ban is just the start.
Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by fastball on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:58PM (#24972443)
Not sure why you think all the originalists on the SCOTUS would want to death-by-a-thousand cuts Roe v Wade.

If states pass constitutional laws, I'm sure they'll be upheld by the current SCOTUS. If laws are unconstitutional, I'm sure they won't be.

What is the problem here? That originalist conservatives won't be legislating from the bench as has been happening? If abortion needs to be a protected right then amend the constitution.

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by AshWolfy on Monday November 02, 2020 @04:02PM (#24973305)
Because of different interpretations of the constitution. What do you believe constitutes a reasonable health regulation?
Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by fastball on Monday November 02, 2020 @08:23PM (#24975392)
Whatever you can pass as long as it doesn't violate the constitution.
Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by krapp on Monday November 02, 2020 @08:32PM (#24975454)
But in Roe V. Wade, SCOTUS already determined that abortion rights don't violate the constitution.

Why do you believe a constitutional amendment is necessary for a right already determined to be constitutional?

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by fennecfoxen on Monday November 02, 2020 @08:48PM (#24975542)
It is possible that this was decided in error. The reasoning referred to it using fuzzy terms about “emanations” and “penumbras” from the fourth amendment, and the right thus found is not clearly stated by the text of the law (let alone the intent of those who wrote it). The late RBG sorta thought it was trash as an opinion.

An explicit constitutional amendment would establish it much more firmly, and would be impeccably legitimate in precisely the way Roe isn’t. These are very desirable properties if you value democracy, or if you wish to establish things more permanently.

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by krapp on Monday November 02, 2020 @09:58PM (#24975900)
I don't know that RGB thought it was trash as an opinion. She believed in a woman's right to an abortion, but also believed the basis for the decision in Roe V Wade was weak and its scope made it vulnerable to attack (and she was correct in hindsight.) From what I read, she believed a stronger argument could have been made from the equal protection clause rather than right to privacy. But she certainly believed the underlying right was valid.

But let's be honest - almost no one opposing Roe V. Wade does so on the grounds that the argument from the fourth amendment is weak, they argue primarily from religious grounds that pregnant women fundamentally do not have the right to terminate, as they consider such to be an act of murder in nearly all, or all cases.

The crux of the matter regarding abortion for most people has never really been a legalistic one but a metaphysical and often religious one - the rights of the unborn versus the rights of a woman's autonomy over her body.

While I would hope that Republicans who drape themselves in Christian piety and refer to themselves as pro-life in order to imply that their opponents are pro-death, and who have made an existential pillar out of repealing Roe V. Wade for forty years, would stack the courts with judges who would consider the matter without undue bias, I suspect that bias is the intent for stacking the court to begin with,and that the actual constitutional validity of the decision isn't meant to matter.

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by fennecfoxen on Monday November 02, 2020 @10:44PM (#24976091)
> I suspect that bias is the intent for stacking the court to begin with, and that the actual constitutional validity of the decision isn't meant to matter.

I regret that your post has derailed this conversation into a sectarian display of othering, aversion, and moralization. No further productive exchanges on the topic will be found here.

I will instead note that when we treat our ideological opponents as respectable people who are capable of walking and chewing gum at the same time (so to speak) it is not because we expect that our enemies will reap the benefits of this respect. It is for our own sake that we ought do this.

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by krapp on Monday November 02, 2020 @11:14PM (#24976215)
I never claimed anyone was incapable of walking and chewing gum at the same time, merely that a political party acts with political motives.

That the Republican Party has sought the repeal of Roe V. Wade since the decision was made, and that the primary impetus behind that is religious, rather than legalistic, is so obvious that it should be banal. They literally campaign on getting justices in to repeal Roe V. Wade. Yet you've suddenly turned defensive and accused me of moralizing and condescending simply by mentioning it.

It probably is best to table this. It's futile to even try to have a decent political conversation here anyway.

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by wycy on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:13PM (#24972644)
The idea that the conservatives on the court are "originalists" is a complete farce. Kavanaugh just wrote an opinion last week that it is critical that election results must be called by TV networks on the night of the election. This is of course despite the fact that (a) there is no such law, (b) none of the founding fathers could have ever imagined TV networks calling elections day-of, (c) and election results are routinely not known for many days/weeks after an election. This bizarre opinion is just one of countless that disproves the "originalism" myth.

And as for legislating from the bench, few are more guilty of that than Alito and Thomas.

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by fastball on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:39PM (#24972985)
Um. What?

The case I think you're talking about (DNC v WSL) was literally about whether or not state legislatures can decide when to require ballots. Wisconsin's legislature decided election day. A lower court said this was unconstitutional, but it's not, so the majority opinion was for WSL.

Please show me where in this opinion the assertion was made that election results must be called by TV networks on election night.

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by wycy on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:50PM (#24973144)
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/10/27/us/kavanaugh-voting-right...

Also funny about his opinion is that he doesn't seem to understand that states rarely (never?) "definitively announced results on election night." States typically don't certify their results for weeks. Only TV networks call elections on election night based on projections of what the final results might be after states count all their legally cast ballots. Kavanaugh either doesn't understand or has a problem with how elections in this country have always worked.

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by fastball on Monday November 02, 2020 @04:08PM (#24973376)
Huh, literally nothing about announcing results on TV.

How can you straight-facedly opine on the opinion when you clearly haven't read it? Instead of reading a NYT article, which is basically a partisan rag at this point, try reading the actual opinion.

And then you can quote back to me the parts about television. Except you can't, because they're not there.

> Kavanaugh just wrote an opinion last week that it is critical that election results must be called by TV networks on the night of the election.

This is a lie. Stop lying.

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by wycy on Monday November 02, 2020 @04:25PM (#24973588)
Media networks are the only entities that can call an election on election night. States can't and don't do that. Therefore, Kavanaugh is either talking about (1) the networks "calling" the election or (2) he's talking about some fantasy world in which states certify their elections night-of. Either is lunacy and either flies in the face of originalism.

I have a lot of problems with NYT, including ideological problems, but to say it's just a partisan rag tells me all I need to know about this conversation.

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by fastball on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:14PM (#24974113)
How can you say that and not agree that it is a partisan rag?

A reputable news org shouldn't have a handful of problems, much less "a lot". And certainly not blatantly obvious ideological / bias problems.

Back to SCOTUS, the quote was:

> Those states also want to be able to definitively announce the results of the election on election night, or as soon as possible thereafter.

Emphasis mine. Nowhere did the majority opinion say "certify" the results. States (or to be more precise, the districts within them) absolutely do start reporting their results on election night.

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by wycy on Saturday November 14, 2020 @06:06PM (#25096537)
Now that we're 2 weeks after the election, zero states have reported final results, and all of our understanding is based on TV networks calling the results, have you changed your tune on this?
Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by fastball on Saturday November 14, 2020 @11:49PM (#25098346)
What did I say that is no longer true now?
Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by wycy on Sunday November 15, 2020 @09:04PM (#25107145)
Living through the past 2 weeks reiterates that Kavanaugh’s opinion was implicitly about AP/NYT/CNN being able to call the election despite the guise of “originalism”
Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by fastball on Sunday November 15, 2020 @11:39PM (#25108075)
I’m confused, wasn’t your original claim that it was implicitly talking about states calling the election, not news networks?

And from there, it’s pretty clear that indecision around the election (and specifically mail-in voting) has indeed caused issues, so if anything the last two weeks affirm the SCOTUS majority opinion.

Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by wycy on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:40AM (#25112158)
The point was that Kavanaugh's opinion was that networks must call the election night-of or immediately thereafter, which is not an originalist interpretation.
Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally? by fastball on Monday November 16, 2020 @11:09AM (#25113327)
That is definitely not what the opinion said.