Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally?
by toolz on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:19PM
(#24971931)
yeah the author isn't very credible but the data is sourced and the point seems to stand as far as I can tell. The sources do not seem to be contested as far as I can tell.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally?
by gruez on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:40PM
(#24972198)
>but the data is sourced and the point seems to stand as far as I can tell.
Doesn't that describe most pseudoscience/conspiracy posts though? They rarely make up data outright, but instead they cherrypick data that fits their theory. This is why I asked if this theory was already a thing before the pandemic. If it's really the case that China (or any other major emitter) is underreporting their emissions, you'd think that someone at a reputable institution would have raised the alarm about the inconsistency in the past two decades. The lack of this is a reason to doubt the validity of this, at least to a casual observer.
With regards to actual explanations, the twitter thread provides many:
* chinese new year
* sanctions/tariffs
* different style of lockdown by china vs the US
Re:Is it better to plant trees or let forests regrow naturally?
by toolz on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:03PM
(#24972525)
conspiracy theory? As I understand it this is merely measuring data and comparing it to previous measurements. Either the data is wrong or it isn't - there's no need to complicate things with conspiracy theories or anything else