News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by dahart on Monday November 02, 2020 @09:35AM (#24968505)
Apparently days are slightly longer now (up to 0.06 microseconds) just in the last 10 year because of the enormous dam in China. 1 leap second every 16M years, I wonder if that’s enough to care about right now? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three_Gorges_Dam#Terrestrial_i...

Time smear is an interesting concept. Once enough of the world’s clocks are synced to online sources, I wonder if we should consider using that kind of idea to smear away daylight savings time over the whole year. Not sure it’s a great idea, but maybe it would be possible to set the sunrise to be 7am every day.

Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by fanf2 on Monday November 02, 2020 @10:02AM (#24968793)
One of the earlier proposals for DST suggested shifting by 20 minutes four times in spring and back four times in autumn. Counting hours from sunrise or sunset (instead of noon) was common in the ancient world. (They were often rubber hours so there were always 12 hours of day and 12 of night regardless of the season.)

Some years ago I sketched a way to do smoothed DST based on when the sun rises. The trick is to avoid time zone differences due to differences in latitude (as well as longitude). I chose to use sunrise at the nearest tropic as the benchmark, which gives you a gradual DST adjustment of about an hour and a half between winter and summer, changing by up to a minute or two each day. http://catless.ncl.ac.uk/Risks/search?query=Sunrise+time+Fin...

Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by dahart on Monday November 02, 2020 @11:09AM (#24969615)
Yes exactly, I like this proposal! "The essential idea is that our clocks should be set using sunrise as a benchmark instead of noon." Are you pursuing it, and did you get any valuable feedback?
Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by fanf2 on Monday November 02, 2020 @11:39AM (#24969975)
Well, it was originally intended as satire (hence the reference to Jonathan Swift in the subject line) - even though its logic makes some kind of sense, it is completely impractical :-) I do have a bit of sketchy software that compares various times (local apparent solar time, local mean solar time, standard/daylight time, smoothed sunrise-based time, times of sunrise/noon/sunset) but I have never found a good enough reference for the astronomical calculations to be happy with it.
Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by dahart on Monday November 02, 2020 @11:55AM (#24970203)
Oh jeez, hahaha whoosh, the joke went totally over my head - is that whole publication satire? Do you think it's becoming more likely to be practical over time? I'd guess it's still impractical, but the percent of the world's online-connected clocks has definitely skyrocketed in the last 10 years with the proliferation of smart phones...
Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by fanf2 on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:34PM (#24971410)
RISKS is mostly sensible though it has a sense of humour especially around the 1st April :-)

RISKS is one of the oldest mailing lists, since 1985, worth subscribing if you have an interest in computer systems security.

Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by Someone on Monday November 02, 2020 @11:52AM (#24970147)
Would that work well with zoom meetings where participants aren’t on the same latitude? I would think the difference in time of sunrise between them varies during the year (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunrise_equation). If so, repeated appointments would have to move for at least one of them. In itself that isn’t problematic, but if one also has appointments with people on the same latitude, non-overlapping events might start overlapping over time.

Also, why stop at sunrise, and discriminate against sunset? Do what the Romans did: always have 12 hours between sunrise and sunset and 12 between sunset and sunrise (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_timekeeping#Variation) :-)

Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by dahart on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:04PM (#24970323)
Oh yeah, I never even thought about latitudinal time zones! It could be a checkerboard. Or maybe we need diagonal stripes and not vertical stripes. Now I need to plot the isolines of sunrise on the globe... looks like I'm not getting anything done today... thanks! ;) Or I guess we could entrust the Google cloud to keep time and sync all the calendars.

12 hours of sun is a crazy idea, now that's some time smear. It'd be funny to try that in Iceland or Svalbard, where you'd end up with days where 12 hours are divided into 10 minutes... or worse, some days with no hours at all!

Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by Someone on Monday November 02, 2020 @04:58PM (#24973928)
“Isolines of sunrise on the globe” don’t exist/change with time of year. It’s more like there’s a “sunrise line” that runs around the globe, changing slowly with a one year period (ignoring lots of smaller effects)

If you really want to complicate things, a real “7 ‘o clock at local sunrise” clock should also be affected by local mountains.

If you really, really want to complicate things, include cloud cover, too, an require that sunrise must be observed (Muslims require that for the new moon to determine the end of Ramadan (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ramadan#Eid))

Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by dahart on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @09:23AM (#24989284)
Huh? The sunrise line is what I was talking about.

The rest of that is hilarious. I have no interest to complicate things in those ways, but if you think those are good ideas, you should go for it! Propose them to your local government and try to get them to switch.

Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by dmurray on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:34PM (#24970697)
> Now I need to plot the isolines of sunrise on the globe... looks like I'm not getting anything done today... thanks! ;)

You can try different times on this page, for one:

https://www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/sunearth.html

Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by dahart on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:11PM (#24971092)
Yes! There they are, the diagonal time zones. I don't know why I didn't check there. This website is so amazingly good, I keep referencing the interactive annual sunrise/sunset charts at different locations, just didn't think to check the world map. For some reason I feel like maybe the pastel colors and cartoony graphics make me frequently under-estimate how serious and thorough the charts and apps are here, but I am a big fan. Maybe time to donate.
Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by tzs on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:12PM (#24970431)
Zoom meeting with people in significantly different latitudes would be like meetings now with people in significantly different longitudes. The same mechanisms we use to cope with the latter should work with the former.
Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by Someone on Monday November 02, 2020 @04:42PM (#24973765)
Time zones (even if daylight saving time switches aren’t synchronized) are a tamed version of synchronizing every clock with local sunrise. Things such as “Let’s meet next month, same time” wouldn’t make sense anymore.

Everybody would have to know what location a meeting is scheduled in. “An hour after sunrise in London” would be the same for everyone, but if you also meetings “two hours after sunrise in Madrid” and “three hours after sunrise in Paris”, how much time there is between them will vary during the year.

Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by tzs on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:04PM (#24970318)
I think it could work to have a dual time system, with a worldwide time (probably UTC) used when you are trying to coordinate things with people who are not in your general region and a regional time based on sunrise (which I'd put at 6 AM, probably).

Most people would have their clocks/watches/devices display regional time, or both regional and world time.

Things like business hours, school hours, meal times, regional transit schedules, and other things that mostly just involve coordinating with people in the region would use regional time.

For most people in a region, this would allow them to operate on a schedule that involves waking naturally to the brightening morning instead of using an alarm. It would also mean that all of the extra daylight hours that come with the summer would end up at the end of the day, instead of some of them going before you go to work or in more northern places even before you wake up.

Re:Why is subtracting these two times in 1927 giving a stran... by iso1210 on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:58PM (#24971682)
> a regional time based on sunrise (which I'd put at 6 AM, probably).

So sunset at noon?