Re:Don’t tell people to “Google it.” That’s your job, not th...
by lordnacho on Sunday November 01, 2020 @03:50PM
(#24962402)
The point about sources on the internet being of dubious quality is quite important. The ability to critique sources is utterly missing from a lot of people's education, and it took the internet to expose it.
It's also one of the most frustrating things to explain to someone when their "research" is wrong:
"Yes, I know he's called doctor in those early papers, he was struck off the register. No, it doesn't cause autism, that was made up. No, I'm not a doctor, but I'm not the one making the claims."
All those rebuttals require a diversion that wouldn't be necessary to explain if people were educated in how to assess sources.
I don't know what to do about it, because it manifests as a dubious presentation of crappy sources, but the explanation of what makes a credible source itself is a long and somewhat vague story:
- Other credible sources support it
- Independent sources support it
- Connects with existing models of the world
- History of being credible
- Incentives align, no obvious conflicts
All of those are things for which you can create an alternate universe. Your own network of outlets that support each other, your own flat-earth physics and lizardmen politics, and your own history.
It's also one of the most frustrating things to explain to someone when their "research" is wrong:
"Yes, I know he's called doctor in those early papers, he was struck off the register. No, it doesn't cause autism, that was made up. No, I'm not a doctor, but I'm not the one making the claims."
All those rebuttals require a diversion that wouldn't be necessary to explain if people were educated in how to assess sources.
I don't know what to do about it, because it manifests as a dubious presentation of crappy sources, but the explanation of what makes a credible source itself is a long and somewhat vague story:
- Other credible sources support it
- Independent sources support it
- Connects with existing models of the world
- History of being credible
- Incentives align, no obvious conflicts
All of those are things for which you can create an alternate universe. Your own network of outlets that support each other, your own flat-earth physics and lizardmen politics, and your own history.