Re:The Complete Idiot’s Guide to the Independence of the Con...
by pdonis on Sunday November 01, 2020 @04:54PM
(#24962862)
> It's also not possible to define the natural numbers using any first order theory.
Yes, agreed.
> you were originally right that no theory of the reals can be satisfied by the rationals, but that's for a fairly unrelated reason.
Can you elaborate?
Re:The Complete Idiot’s Guide to the Independence of the Con...
by Kranar on Sunday November 01, 2020 @05:19PM
(#24963042)
At a minimum any theory of real numbers will imply a theorem of the form "There exists an x such that x * x = 2". The set of rational numbers doesn't contain any such x and hence the rational numbers will not satisfy any theory of real numbers.
Having said that, you were originally right that no theory of the reals can be satisfied by the rationals, but that's for a fairly unrelated reason.