News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by nickpeterson on Sunday November 01, 2020 @10:13AM (#24959972)
I don't understand the issue? Decisions are just a state machine getting different inputs. It's the same for trees and humans.
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by jwmhjwmh on Sunday November 01, 2020 @10:29AM (#24960074)
The article says the organism tries several approaches in succession to escape the unpleasant carmine. This still isn't super advanced behavior, but it's interesting considering the organism is single-celled.
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by JumpCrisscross on Sunday November 01, 2020 @10:37AM (#24960144)
> the organism tries several approaches in succession to escape the unpleasant carmine

This implies memory. Venus fly traps use calcium gradients for short-term memory [1]. It would be interesting to learn how this organism remembers.

[1] https://www.sciencenews.org/article/how-venus-flytraps-store...

Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by im3w1l on Sunday November 01, 2020 @02:19PM (#24961761)
> This implies memory.

Shouldn't be too surprising.

"In genetics, a promoter is a sequence of DNA to which proteins bind that initiate transcription of a single RNA from the DNA downstream of it. This RNA may encode a protein, or can have a function in and of itself, such as tRNA, mRNA, or rRNA. Promoters are located near the transcription start sites of genes, upstream on the DNA (towards the 5' region of the sense strand)."

In programming terminology, the promoter region listens for events, and is followed by a handler body. So protein concentrations can be used for state.

Regarding the calcium gradients you mentioned, I wonder... I think they are more about inter-cellular communication. Cells can use calcium to make electricity. Calcium is also used by neurons to send electric pulses.

I actually find it fascinating that neurons are not unique in using electricity to communicate - that an analog exists in the plant world.

Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by LaserPineapple on Sunday November 01, 2020 @03:51PM (#24962411)
What does it remember? The approach tried previously?
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by loa_in_ on Monday November 02, 2020 @12:09AM (#24964994)
Probably stress level, and the approach that follows, follows from that.
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by jtsiskin on Sunday November 01, 2020 @10:36AM (#24960135)
Yes, but it’s a richer state machine than previously thought, and we aren’t aware of the mechanisms it’s using for internal state
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by xipho on Sunday November 01, 2020 @11:26AM (#24960494)
I think this is the key. "Just a state-machine" is a gross over-simplification. Imagine a tiny fruit-fly brain, vastly smaller than a human brain. Remarkably we can slice that brain into over 4000 pieces and try and rebuilt the connectome, which is a huge challenge in and of itself. Describing what's going on there as "state-machine" miss-represents a computer-science definition of "state-machine", and doesn't remotely reflect the biological complexity going on.
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by throwaway_pdp09 on Sunday November 01, 2020 @12:49PM (#24961131)
Whether it's more complex than a state machine can model (doubtful[0]) and whether it "doesn't remotely reflect the biological complexity" may be true but the guy's point still stands, it's a mechanism that can be modelled.

[0] you'd have to inject non-determinism as well.

Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by xyhopguy on Sunday November 01, 2020 @01:10PM (#24961282)
non-determinism can also be modeled as a state-machine (and in fact, you can prove non-deterministic state machines can always be represented by deterministic state machines).
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by throwaway_pdp09 on Sunday November 01, 2020 @01:22PM (#24961356)
Ugh, you're right and I used completely the wrong terminology. I meant some degree of randomness (I think the posh term is stochastic-something), noise, jitter etc. Not NFA/DFA stuff. Good catch and thanks.
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by ncmncm on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:24PM (#24971980)
They get to do more than a state machine, because they can do analog computation.

You can simulate that with a state machine, but only with one that is much more complicated. Nature doesn't exactly prefer simplicity, but it's very bad at discovering solutions that need a big jump in complexity compared to a previous generation.

Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by jfk13 on Sunday November 01, 2020 @12:21PM (#24960928)
Maybe. We don't know that. You take it on faith, apparently, but that doesn't prove anything.
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by throwaway_pdp09 on Sunday November 01, 2020 @12:47PM (#24961112)
If you believe in a soul, and if you believe that a single celled organism (SCO) has a soul, then you can indeed delegate decision making to a non-corporeal entity. Not saying that's wrong but I struggle to accept that.
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by jfk13 on Sunday November 01, 2020 @01:32PM (#24961409)
Or you might believe that a single celled organism can reasonably be understood as a state machine responding to inputs, but that a human -- or a tree, or a cat -- is not merely a scaled-up version of this same model.

We are far from knowing whether this is the case. So you can believe one extreme or the other (or something in between), but either way it's an article of faith, not an established fact.

Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by throwaway_pdp09 on Sunday November 01, 2020 @01:40PM (#24961462)
Please clarify because I don't know - are you invoking the existence of a soul in the decision making process?

If so, you're bringing in something that's purely a matter of faith as no evidence has ever been found of a soul (AFAIK).

If no soul then be it single-celled or human, we're back in the mechanistic world and one is, somehow, just a more elaborate version of the other.

Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by jfk13 on Sunday November 01, 2020 @03:28PM (#24962220)
We have no more evidence that what we experience as consciousness and decision-making arises from the operation of a purely mechanistic state machine than we have for the existence of a soul.

Some people believe that when the machine becomes sufficiently complex, consciousness will emerge. Others don't. Either way, it's a matter of faith.

Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by throwaway_pdp09 on Sunday November 01, 2020 @03:38PM (#24962302)
So the answer is yes, you're invoking the existence of a soul. It is not honest to duck a simple but pivotal and explicit question.

> We have no more evidence...arises from the operation of a purely mechanistic state machine than we have for the existence of a soul.

Evidence of a soul: 0%. Evidence of atoms: 99.999999999999999999% or higher.

Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by ncmncm on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:09PM (#24971814)
Appreciate the attempt at engagement, but precision is not seen as helpful for "that kind" of discussion.

Ultimately, "you do you" is as much resolution as can reasonably be expected, down such a rabbithole.

Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by jfk13 on Sunday November 01, 2020 @04:52PM (#24962852)
I'm not invoking the existence (or non-existence) of anything. I'm just noting that we are far from understanding what consciousness is, let alone how it works.

(Who said anything about atoms? I didn't.)

Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by codethief on Sunday November 01, 2020 @05:51PM (#24963249)
> I'm just noting that we are far from understanding what consciousness is, let alone how it works.

The fact that we don't know what consciousness is doesn't mean we can't make reasonable guesses. Now, given that we understand both macroscopic and microscopic physics pretty well these days, there is only so much room for guessing and some guesses are much more reasonable than others.

Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by throwaway_pdp09 on Sunday November 01, 2020 @05:19PM (#24963039)
> we are far from understanding what consciousness is, let alone how it works

Couldn't agree more, but that wasn't your original assertion, to wit first para of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24962220

> Who said anything about atoms? I didn't.

You: "...from the operation of a purely mechanistic state machine" So what's a 'purely mechanistic state machine' going to be made of if not atoms.

Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by YeGoblynQueenne on Sunday November 01, 2020 @07:53PM (#24963953)
A link to the HN guidelines:

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Note this one in particular:

  Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation 
  of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier 
  to criticize. Assume good faith. 
Also, don't forget: when you assume, you make an ass of u and me.
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by throwaway_pdp09 on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:19AM (#24965711)
I appreciate the intervention, and I really must learn to let things drop, that said I've been trying to work out what the heck he's saying. I haven't knowingly responded to a weaker argument.
Re:Single-Celled Organism Appears to Make Decisions (2019) by mensetmanusman on Sunday November 01, 2020 @06:51PM (#24963607)
Energy