News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why we need an Open Wireless movement by ChuckMcM on Thursday April 28, 2011 @07:32PM (#2495611)
Sigh.

How about this idea, we create device that can send digital data by modulating and demodulating sounds which can be sent from one computer to another. Then we'll invent a store and forward protocol where you could type in a message on a local computer, and that message would then move between you and its recipient through a series of jumps we will call "hops." [you know, like its hopping from computer to computer]. You could send a message from anywhere to anywhere else just by putting in the places it had to go between here and there. We could even create a system where by we can create a category or subject area and messages can be sent to everyone who wants to read them on those messages. The coolest thing is that because its just computer to computer there is no evil mastermind in the middle pulling the strings and we'll have the source code to everything so that anyone can become part of the network. It will be a network for the users and we'll call it User Network, no that doesn't sound quite right, I've got it Usenet.

Silly history lesson aside, connections aren't "free" and the people who pay the bills set the rules, if you don't like the rules pay for your own network. You can argue the prices are fixed or too high. Fine. You can get a USB Softradio and the Gnu Radio stack and create your own white space wireless.

But moaning about the fact that no one is willing to give you "the nice one" free access to their network becasue they can't also prevent "the bad one" from getting access is a phenomenal waste of time.

We can probably have 'free' wireless for anyone as long as everyone got their own IP address. There is a proposal floating around where the US Government would install wired and wireless networks everywhere like the interstate highway system, and then individuals would apply for their own block of IP:V6 address space. In that world everything you owned would then 'DHCP' off your personal address space. And every packet you sent would be tracable right back to you. Last I heard both the MPAA and RIAA thought this was a great idea of tax payer funded network so that everyone, rich or poor, had equal access to a quality internet experience.

Its not free. It never has been.

Re:Why we need an Open Wireless movement by ChuckMcM on Thursday April 28, 2011 @08:13PM (#2495758)
Always with the negativity. Sheesh. Here is the cliff notes version of the referenced article:

Complaint: Can't find free wireless

Observation: Criminals abuse open wireless networks

Observation: Fewer and fewer networks

Ask: "We" want to reverse trend, encouraging 'free' networks

Ask: Give common carrier protection to someone who opens a wireless network.

Whine: It sucks not to be able to get online.

Strawman #1: Perhaps people want to prioritize their traffic over the freeloaders

Occam's Razor Says: No, the simpler argument is they pay for it and don't want to give it away)

Strawman #2: If a hacker wanted to they could break into your network so you don't buy much by securing it.

Occam's Razor Says: Locking your front door doesn't prevent breakins either but it does keep random strangers from scoping out what is inside your house.

Ask: No cost WiFi that protects the identity of the free loader

Fallacy: There is no protocol that allows anyone to join the network using link layer encryption.

Exception: Opening VPN connections using well established standards.

Strawman: Spectrum auctions were expensive, WiFi makes more efficient use of spectrum.

Exception: FCC just opened up a huge chunk of wide area spectrum for unlicensed use, aka 'white space' from the abandonded TV bands.

Ask: Join with us to whine about the lack of free wireless access points.

Since it isn't 'free' to provide a network connection, you have to make it economically viable. Economics being the force that allocates scarce resources (and network connectivity is once such resource). If you don't pay cash for a 3G connection (or an LTE connection or an EDGE connection) then you have to offer something else. I am really, really tired of hearing people refer to the Internet as "the commons" (as in the original Boston sense and with 'Tragedy of' in the conversation) since the network has never been a 'commons' in any sense of the word or concept. That you grew up and didn't understand who was paying for it and why and got mislead into believing it was 'free' is fine, but don't persist in that mis-information or you might find yourself talking about how all the strangers sleeping in your parent's living room is a 'tragedy of the commons' when its just squatting on your parents property. Its not a 'tragedy of the commons' when there are rolling blackouts because there isn't enough power generating capacity or typhoid because there is an open sewer running by your house. The author wants a world wide, cryptographically secure, communications network that anyone can access for free. Its a pony request [1].

[1] http://i-want-a-pony.com/

Re:Why we need an Open Wireless movement by erikpukinskis on Thursday April 28, 2011 @11:29PM (#2496232)
The other day, someone walked by with their dog and asked if they could get use our hose to give their dog some water. I bit the bullet, and allowed them to take $0.05 worth of water that I had paid for with my hard earned money.

Same deal here. Connectivity is getting to the point where the costs are so low, you might as well give it away to passersby, because seriously, are we really counting nickels and dimes?

Not free, but cheap enough that most of us can be generous with it.

Re:Why we need an Open Wireless movement by ChuckMcM on Friday April 29, 2011 @12:46AM (#2496379)
Point taken.

I had a really funny experience that kind of relates. My sink had some of those poorly made fiber washers, if you weren't careful, which meant if you over-tightened or under-tightened the sink valve when you closed it, it would drip. Just a little bit, you know drip .... drip .... drip ...

Then California got this whole drought thing going and the water company was asking everyone to cut back. We fixed the faucet and saved a bit over 3% on our total overall water bill.

For me in the US I'm fortunate because water is cheap. I find I can't ignore it though.

Re:Why we need an Open Wireless movement by sliverstorm on Friday April 29, 2011 @05:25AM (#2496830)
The difference is with WiFi, someone can take $50.00 worth of service, and you wouldn't even see their face. If someone tried to come up to your house and take $50.00 of water, you'd probably notice.