Re:An Earth-sized rogue planet discovered in the Milky Way
by rlanday on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:57PM
(#24956495)
> Gil Scott-Heron is right - but also not. I was reminded of this watching First Man - and I realised that if 1960s USA had not funded a Moonshot, then would it have looked at itself and said "Hey our police force is used to keep 1/5th of our population in poverty through violence and our financial policies do the same. Let's fix that"?
Well, we have 2020s America as a comparison. Whether or not you think we’ve recognized the problem, it certainly hasn’t been solved to the extent that e.g. we actually flew people to the moon and back.
Re:An Earth-sized rogue planet discovered in the Milky Way
by nxmnxm99 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @07:04PM
(#24955935)
> Until we can convincingly show we agree on what our problems actually are, I am reluctant to think we can spend billions fixing them.
So instead spend billions staring at dead rocks? Going to the moon had tremendous political and strategic value during wartime - the same conditions don’t exist in the world today.
Gil Scott-Heron is right - but also not. I was reminded of this watching First Man - and I realised that if 1960s USA had not funded a Moonshot, then would it have looked at itself and said "Hey our police force is used to keep 1/5th of our population in poverty through violence and our financial policies do the same. Let's fix that"?
The thing about the space race was not how much money it got but how it was allowed to define problems using measurements to the millimetre and then solve them at the edge of what was technically possible.
They were free of politics because no one had ever done it before.
But politics is itself how we decide what the problem is.
The concept that the US could have spent the moon money on fixing its self is ... a stretch.
But to give in to that line of thinking is to abandon all hope.
Not spending money on space is not the same as spending it on fixing our deepest problems.
Until we can convincingly show we agree on what our problems actually are, I am reluctant to think we can spend billions fixing them.
Instead let's fire spaghetti at the walls on local levels - maybe we can find solutions local interventions first.