News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I don't learn anything on HN anymore, bring back the upvo... by wdewind on Thursday April 28, 2011 @06:31PM (#2495395)
You're right about the herd mentality, but that's the whole point: measuring the herd mentality has a value. No one is asking you to put 100% of your judgment in the point count, and you'd be a fool to do so, much as you'd be a fool to believe everything you see on TV.

Showing points does not kill HNers brains. We've already lost if it does.

Re:I don't learn anything on HN anymore, bring back the upvo... by ericd on Thursday April 28, 2011 @06:53PM (#2495473)
It has far less value than you might think. When this community was 100% startuppers, that worked better, but now there are so many people who don't have first hand experience that are willing to upvote anything that sounds correct that it's lost a lot of its value. It's now a dangerous positive feedback loop.

High vote counts tend to be very convincing to all but the most discriminating people, it's not the mark of a fool to believe what everyone is telling them is correct, just a sign of inexperience with that topic.

Re:I don't learn anything on HN anymore, bring back the upvo... by wdewind on Thursday April 28, 2011 @07:10PM (#2495532)
What you've just told me is the community is broken, not the system.
Re:I don't learn anything on HN anymore, bring back the upvo... by Sakes on Thursday April 28, 2011 @07:27PM (#2495595)
No, what he is saying is that the system that worked for a small community of like minded individuals does not work for a large diverse community.

The upvote system used to work because it consisted of a lot of similar people saying, this is a good point, or I like this.

Today's community is much more diverse, which is inevitable when you have a quality service/product/community/yadda yadda.

>> In total, Hacker News now sees about 90,000 unique visitors per day. http://newsgrange.com/ycombinators-hacker-news-reaches-1-mil...

The old system just doesn't mean what it used to. People are looking for new strats to preserve the original culture as best they can.

Re:I don't learn anything on HN anymore, bring back the upvo... by wdewind on Thursday April 28, 2011 @07:50PM (#2495673)
I don't really disagree with your premises, but please explain how removing upvotes fixed the problem.
Re:I don't learn anything on HN anymore, bring back the upvo... by Sakes on Friday April 29, 2011 @11:39AM (#2497729)
I could see it going a couple of different ways.

1) It actually has improved comment rankings.

2) or I am just experiencing a placebo affect.

- 1: If it actually fixed the problem, this would mean that quality comments will appear higher on the page, not cluttered by mediocre comments that enjoy the group bump. I pull this assumption based upon the way I use the upvote system. So of course, I could be wrong.

- 2: Maybe the site just feels better to me, because I don't have to see comments get high upvotes that I believe are poorly thought out, or based highly on emotion/fanboyism/or other non logical motivations.

I could see it going either way, but my money is on the first possibility.

All I know for sure is that I now rarely find myself thinking.."Whaat? People think that was a good comment? People thought that added value? People think this guy knows what he's talking about?"

Re:I don't learn anything on HN anymore, bring back the upvo... by billswift on Thursday April 28, 2011 @10:09PM (#2496074)
I think it has made the problem worse, sharply worse.
Re:I don't learn anything on HN anymore, bring back the upvo... by ericd on Thursday April 28, 2011 @07:29PM (#2495604)
It's just not as self-selecting as it used to be. What worked for the community in the past doesn't necessarily work now or going forward. At least a bit of regression to the mean in the community is inevitable if it grows (which it has, by a lot).