News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Genesis of requiring a "Dropbox folder," versus designate... by Splines on Thursday April 28, 2011 @03:13PM (#2494687)
It's most definitely a more easily understood mental model.

I also run Live Mesh to sync my music between work/home, because it has the neat feature of non-server syncing (it allows you to sync an arbitrary amount of data, but only between two client PCs, no server storage).

However, an odd feature in Live Mesh is the capability to add an already-syncing folder to an existing machine in the group. There's no UI to allow you pick where on the remote PC you want the data to end up, so it's possible to push a bunch of data to a drive that you didn't want to.

Plus, moving this data is also weird:

- Stop syncing the folder

- Move the folder

- Ask to sync the folder, and point to the new location

There's a certain level of "is this going to work?" going on in your head when you complete that last step. I'm guessing this sort of problem exists in both Live Mesh and Dropbox, although with the single-folder paradigm in dropbox, this scenario probably doesn't happen that often.

Re:Genesis of requiring a "Dropbox folder," versus designate... by w1ntermute on Thursday April 28, 2011 @03:46PM (#2494821)
> It's most definitely a more easily understood mental model.

That doesn't mean they shouldn't offer an alternative for those would prefer to sync specific folders. I've ended up simulating this behavior by using symlinks, but that's a real hacky solution and still doesn't solve the problem of selective syncing.

Re:Genesis of requiring a "Dropbox folder," versus designate... by nchlswu on Thursday April 28, 2011 @03:54PM (#2494855)
They definitely realize that they have to offer some sort of solution, hence his "stay tuned."

It was a big UX and strategy choice to offer the a one folder dropbox and it paid off. Now's when they can roll out what people want.

Re:Genesis of requiring a "Dropbox folder," versus designate... by Groxx on Thursday April 28, 2011 @06:24PM (#2495364)
They do. Run the betas, you can change the folder's location and run "selective sync" - just set it to C: and turn everything off that you don't want to save.
Re:Genesis of requiring a "Dropbox folder," versus designate... by w1ntermute on Thursday April 28, 2011 @06:47PM (#2495449)
I'm running the experimental version on Linux, and I see that they do have a selective sync option. But I don't see how to specify a generic folder to be synced. All I can do is change the location of the "Dropbox" folder.