Re:Why Apple didn't use X for the window system
by nailer on Friday July 18, 2008 @03:37AM
(#249532)
Why would it have to replace the existing drawing model? I'm thinking of a way for an app to ask the server if it can render a particular set of high level primitives, if the server responds that it can, the apps sends those instead.
That would allow existing apps and existing display servers, new apps and older display server, and old apps and newer display servers to work fine.
If both the app (at the toolkit level) and the display server are recent, however, remoting is massively sped up.
And it would make writing apps more difficult -- very few of them use entirely stock widgets, and it would be nearly impossible to securely and performantly implement new widgets on this system.
Plus, it's diametrically opposed to the X "Mechanism, not policy" mantra.
I wouldn't expect anything like this to take off, but it's been tried in the Y window system, and more interestingly -- and more dead-in-the-water -- in the NEWS window system.