Re:Show HN: Tara – A free Jira alternative, now with Gitlab
by alkonaut on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:32AM
(#24940264)
The prefix is just a project name though? It's no different from a convention saying that IDs 1000XXX are for project A and IDs for 2000XXX are for project B, it's just easier to read and distinguish like PROJA-0001 and PROJB-0001.
Obviously, you wouldn't want to have things migrating between projects - but if that is even concievable for an issue to do, then the division in 2 projects was probably not correct and it should perhaps have been a single project. That is: the PROJA-0001 is as immutable and unchanging as 1000001 is.
A thing changing "kind" (e.g. a bug to a feature) doesn't seem far fetched, and I'd be reluctant (Meaning I think it would be a flawed design) to use that as the public identifier prefix for a feature.
Obviously, you wouldn't want to have things migrating between projects - but if that is even concievable for an issue to do, then the division in 2 projects was probably not correct and it should perhaps have been a single project. That is: the PROJA-0001 is as immutable and unchanging as 1000001 is.
A thing changing "kind" (e.g. a bug to a feature) doesn't seem far fetched, and I'd be reluctant (Meaning I think it would be a flawed design) to use that as the public identifier prefix for a feature.