News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The only wrong answer is 50/50: Calculating the co-founde... by vessenes on Thursday April 28, 2011 @12:08PM (#2493843)
Interesting comment; in my experience 49.9% is worth a lot less than 50.1%, in fact, I once sold out a minority stake in a company I had originally retained majority ownership. My council told me typical valuation cut for a minority, non-controlling share was like half.

This implies to me you should really shoot for 50%, and make sure you like your joint decision-making process. Of course when you get some funding in, one of you will have to agree with investors to force something through the chain.

Re:The only wrong answer is 50/50: Calculating the co-founde... by brudgers on Thursday April 28, 2011 @12:45PM (#2494021)
Differences in equity often make little difference in terms of control, e.g. in an YC like 8/46/46 split all three have equal control when push comes to shove. Even in Shapiro's three way example, control is equally distributed.

Even with a Shapiro type 55/45 split, once the firm takes significant outside investment (or provides employees meaningful equity); the balance of control will shift to where the founders have to work together as equals. An advantage of the Spolsky approach is that the company operates that way from day one, and outside investment might be less likely to disrupt the decision making process.

Re:The only wrong answer is 50/50: Calculating the co-founde... by kelnos on Friday April 29, 2011 @04:36AM (#2496755)
Another way to look at your point is that once you get outside investment, "control" between the founders is irrelevant, so you should reward the founders up-front based on merit (as Shapiro's article suggests) instead of based on some soon-obsolete notion of who controls the company.
Re:The only wrong answer is 50/50: Calculating the co-founde... by brudgers on Friday April 29, 2011 @09:00AM (#2497174)
In real life, I would have no problem with your suggesting Shapiro's model for initial unequal equity split - so long as you wind up with the least shares. And that's the issue - it makes initial equity split more likely to be competitive or contentious when the stakes are likely to be very low or zero.
Re:The only wrong answer is 50/50: Calculating the co-founde... by vessenes on Friday April 29, 2011 @12:08PM (#2497852)
My point exactly, two people who don't even know each other find it easy to argue about unequal stake splitting. Actually, this is Joel's point. I merely recapitulate. :)