Re:After AT&T Ruling, Should We Say Goodbye to Consumer Clas...
by hncommenter13 on Thursday April 28, 2011 @03:55AM
(#2492563)
1. It's easy to name a ruling on a statute that was then revised--this is not that uncommon. Try http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ledbetter_v._Goodyear_Tire_%26_.... The Court's ruling hewed close to the text of Title VII, but Congress didn't like the outcome, so it changed the law.
2. The Federal Arbitration Act was originally enacted in 1925 (and has been amended and interpreted quite a bit over the years, obviously). Today's Congress is not composed of the same representatives who passed the act, nor does its view of arbitration necessarily reflect the view of those who enacted it originally.
3. This is not a cut-and-dried liberal vs. conservative issue. There are complicated issues of preemption of state laws by the FAA, and what constitutes "unconscionability" in an arbitration agreement--which has been in the Court quite a bit lately (see Rent-a-Center v. Jackson from last term).
Remember these are the same representatives that passed the Federal Arbitration Act. That act and this ruling make it all but impossible to punish corporations for malfeasance. This is why it's important to vote. Whoever leads this country will have an impact not for the next 4-8 years, but possibly 20-30. This ruling was made 5-4 along party lines. The majority were Reagan, Bush I, and Bush II candidates. Remember that when someone tells you they won't vote because they don't like either party.