Re:Consumer Reports: Cadillac's Super Cruise Outperforms Tes...
by pandaman on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:27PM
(#24938172)
Consider a compiler that compiles some malformed programs (e.g. replaces misspelled identifiers with a closest match, ignores missing ';'s etc). Will you want your Tesla's software to be compiled with such a compiler or would you prefer they used the strictest compiler available with extra linting with something like Coverity?
The same sentiment is for critical systems in a car: them working when they should not work is not an amazing feat of engineering but a defect.
wow, just wow. that is just as contrived as can be.
as for amount of torque required to deactivate the self driving it not a lot and why would you assume you want the car to retake control immediately afterward? If I took control I want control till I state otherwise. I don't want to suddenly find the car off doing what it wants after I disengaged it through a method they defined as will turn it off.
So no, I do not agree with their safety assessment because the majority ignores the fact that it was designed to drive in those conditions and not require rigidly mapped roads to operate. There is no real point in self driving system that requires perfection in roads and markings.
Hell the scariest part about Tesla's FSD is how well it does work, it makes you wonder why so many cannot get even part way there.
Is it perfect, not on your life. However it is damn better than CR implies and the only real danger is some people might trust it too much regardless how much Tesla says not to. Well guess what, they do that will all LKA and even super cruise.