Re:Consumer Reports: Cadillac's Super Cruise Outperforms Tes...
by criddell on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @03:40PM
(#24923240)
> you could transfer liability to a government entity
That sounds like a good idea. Legislate a fixed payout schedule and manage it centrally. Society in general benefits and so it makes sense that society in general should be responsible for the harms.
Re:Consumer Reports: Cadillac's Super Cruise Outperforms Tes...
by dllthomas on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @03:05PM
(#24922820)
I think a risk is that courts make a habit of awarding significant penalties because the mistakes the cars are making are less understandable, and so seen as worthy of more blame even though there is less damage actually being done.
Re:Consumer Reports: Cadillac's Super Cruise Outperforms Tes...
by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @03:23PM
(#24923033)
There's well-established rules for what a driver is required to do, and they clearly apply to machines that replace drivers. In general, liability for failure to follow traffic laws and for manufacturers defects are strict liability, so how easy it is to understand the error doesn't really have much room to play a factor in assigning liability, nor is it normally a legal component of assessment of damages once liability were assigned.
If we were talking about liability in a negligence/recklessness regime, “hard to understand innocent errors => more liability awards” is a reasonable model, but in a strict liability regime, that an error is innocent (which being easy to understand makes more likely that a trier of fact, perhaps especially a jury, will find) isn't a mitigation.
I suppose that if you want to keep the sticker prices of vehicles low, you could transfer liability to a government entity in exchange for stronger government oversight and pre-approval of design and manufacturing, and tax vehicle owners (which still should be lower than current costs when added to their insurance costs) to pay for the liability pool.
If you just shield the manufacturers without transferring liability, you are essentially transferring the costs to the injured.