For the self-driving stuff, I really only use the radar cruise control. The car does have lane self-centering but it's not great at detecting lane boundaries, especially when in bad weather or when there's a lot of traffic.
I have that system turned to an advisory mode so it'll beep if I start moving across a lane boundary without a turn signal on.
The radar cruise control is very solid. My only real complaint about it is that it leaves a large gap at low speed; even when in its tightest-follow mode. You can end up getting people merging in front of you, which then causes it to generate an even larger gap. It will take off from a stop, but if it's a long stop it wants you to hit a resume button.
I understand how the systems work at this point, they don't surprise me, and they help with fatigue. I'm generally an attentive driver (I know, we all say that) so I'm OK with the limitations. I don't really want any more.
Very anecdotally, the last time I tried a lane-following system (an Audi rental about two years ago), it tried to kill me by following the off-ramp into a gas station at 65mph.
Surprisingly it’s been around for almost 30 years and Mitsubishi was using Lidar way back in ‘91.
https://www.autonomousvehicleinternational.com/features/adas...
I have personally had experience with Hyundai's systems. Even cheap Elantras have a camera-based system with amazingly good lane centering and some form of auto braking, but they decided to make radar cruise only available for top trims. I got an older 2015 Genesis Sedan with radar cruise (natural but imperfect, and no detection of cars cutting in front of you) and lane keep assist (not quite centering except for every fifth curve where it's too aggressive). The blind spot warning is good but a bit too sensitive. Auto braking is radar based so it warns you appropriately but can't detect pedestrians. The car's driving assistance feels like a beta, which makes sense given its age. The NVH of the Genesis is stellar and the rest of the tech works well.
I also tried Honda's radar cruise in a Clarity and it worked well. When I test drove a TLX, the lane keep assist in the first generation TLX wasn't quite centering. Its braking alert worked fine and I appreciate that since it didn't have the HUD, they put a small LED to project "BRAKE" on the windshield instead.
> Mazda responded that its system was not designed or intended to center the vehicle in a lane and that the automaker doesn’t believe its vehicles are equipped with technology that meets the criteria CR is using in its evaluation.
Not necessarily something I would have understood from its website or brochure. This probably takes the CX-5 off of my short list.
Incidentally, the submitted title casts this as Cadillac vs. Tesla, but the actual title is "Cadillac's Super Cruise Outperforms Other Driving Assistance Systems." In fairness, their 2018 article did have a similar title: "Cadillac Tops Tesla in Consumer Reports' First Ranking of Automated Driving Systems."