Re:Tumblr "Disappears" Microsoft's Danah Boyd
by msravi on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @04:09PM
(#2490898)
So if gmail or yahoo or hotmail or whatever, suddenly decided that your username is trademarked and "moved" your email, without notifying you or giving you a chance to contest the trademark infringement, you'd be ok with it? You'd sympathize with yourself but wouldn't be outraged with their actions?
Re:Tumblr "Disappears" Microsoft's Danah Boyd
by mc32 on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @04:40PM
(#2491017)
I could only expect what they outline in their TOSes.
However, that said, mail is different in that mixing signals (email intended for me going into a mailbox now under control of someone else) might leave them open to liability, depending on what kind of information could be compromised). So, I don't think that would be a valid comparison.
Look, her basic argument was her data (content) was lost, then, learning it wasn't, revised the complaint to, my links are broken. That's moving the goalpost. That was my main point.
Re:Tumblr "Disappears" Microsoft's Danah Boyd
by mc32 on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @05:07PM
(#2491118)
Correct me if I'm wrong, but trademark law does not come into the picture here at all. It's a name collision. Resolution of such are generally relegated to site operator.
No one is claiming she's infringing on their trademark, as far as I know.
It's not outrageous. They did not delete the content -they moved it (at first she complained about losing her data, then retrenched to complaining about broken links -so what was the real problem? She does not own the URL, the site operator does. She made assumptions which proved untrue. The result of such is unfortunate and inconvenient.
It's worthy of a rant of displeasure with how they reach name collision resolution -but it's hardly an affront to the person.
That is to question the "disappeared me" harking to military summary executions of actual physical people? (not online handle). If anything, that's an outrage in itself. A delusion(?) of importance.
I think it's basically a problem of disconnect in expectations.
TL;DR. My data was deleted -I'm upset. Oh, wait, it wasn't; It was moved. I'm pissed anyway.