News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How long does it take to install and try Quicklisp? (a gi... by kruhft on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @01:56PM (#2490389)
I think quicklisp is a great system, but didn't asdf do the same thing? It would download and install packages for you just like ql, so I'm wondering what the obvious advantages of ql are over asdf-install, other than being the hot new thing.
Re:How long does it take to install and try Quicklisp? (a gi... by zachbeane on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @02:04PM (#2490419)
There are a number of ways I think Quicklisp improves on asdf-install. Here are a few:

* Quicklisp centralizes metadata and project archives, so you don't have to rely on a world-writable wiki and 10 random servers on the internet to install a project

* Quicklisp doesn't need any external programs like tar or gzip

* It works nicely on Windows

* There is a level of integration testing before projects are published; it's not much, but it's way better than nothing

* It works with projects that don't go through a formal "release a tarball" process

* It can be installed by loading a single Lisp source file

* It's not named asdf-install, so not confusing people about where asdf stops and asdf-install begins

The main way they do the same thing is at a very high level. I think Quicklisp gets more of the important details right.

Re:How long does it take to install and try Quicklisp? (a gi... by kruhft on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @02:10PM (#2490446)
Thanks for the good response. I'll be taking a closer look into ql as soon as I can.
Re:How long does it take to install and try Quicklisp? (a gi... by zachbeane on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @02:18PM (#2490478)
Also, you can have it both ways: asdf-install is installable via Quicklisp.
Re:How long does it take to install and try Quicklisp? (a gi... by eschulte on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @04:01PM (#2490862)
and to add to this, they play nicely together, so you can asdf-install a new local version of a package available through quicklisp, and (require 'that-package) will load your newer local version.
Re:How long does it take to install and try Quicklisp? (a gi... by slyrus on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @02:07PM (#2490434)
Be careful not to confuse ASDF with ASDF-INSTALL.