Re:The RIAA’s attack on YouTube-dl is not a DMCA 512 infring...
by gamblor956 on Monday October 26, 2020 @07:30PM
(#24902750)
You mostly just restated what I said. The decision merely requires the copyright holder to consider fair use. It doesn't require them to accept that the alleged violation is fair use or even to do a detailed analysis:
In order to comply with the strictures of § 512(c)(3)(A)(v), a copyright holder's consideration of fair use need not be searching or intensive. We follow Rossi's guidance that formation of a subjective good faith belief does not require investigation of the allegedly infringing content
As for the quote, Fair use is not just excused by the law, it is wholly authorized by the law
The court is referring to 17 USC 107. Fair use exists in the context of whether something is a violation of copyright, in the same sense that self-defense is authorized by the law but is still a defense to criminal charges. Notably, I didn't call it an affirmative defense because it is not one.
We hold that the statute requires copyright holders to consider fair use before sending a takedown notification, and that failure to do so raises a triable issue as to whether the copyright holder formed a subjective good faith belief that the use was not authorized by law. [2]
Note that the case was about abuse of DMCA takedowns by copyright holders if not considering fair use. Judge considers fair use as authorized by law, which I would interpret as right, not defense.
Another quote: We agree with the district court and hold that the statute unambiguously contemplates fair use as a use authorized by the law. [2]
Fair use is not just excused by the law, it is wholly authorized by the law [2]
From previously quoted wikipedia article, the paragraph continues:
"Fair use is therefore distinct from affirmative defenses where a use infringes a copyright, but there is no liability due to a valid excuse, e.g., misuse of a copyright." [1]
As for plaintiff considerations, IMO, of course plaintiff is required to argue it's standing, otherwise the case is thrown out, or in this case DMCA is abused. Normally the first bar is to make a coherent argument, then the court gets to decide whether your opinion is right, but that does not lower the defendant's rights to a "defense", even if they are a defense.
[2] Court's decision, hopefully: https://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=125676491686801...