News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: by NumberFiveAlive on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @12:02PM (#2489926)
Is it just me, or does this guy have his definitions swapped. That, or I've been wrong this whole time: I've always thought of hackers as more freewheeling, possibly with less formal training (or possibly not) who like to play with new technologies and learn by getting their hand dirty.

And I've thought of coders as closer to the traditional definition of 'software engineer'. More formalized education (or possibly not), more formal approach to the process of writing code (planning meetings, standards and practices, etc).

I'm not saying either one is better (both have a lot they bring to the table, and few people are all one or the other, we're usually somewhere on a sliding scale between the two).

Re: by j_baker on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @12:13PM (#2489970)
It sounds to me that he may be thinking more in terms of the difference between say an accountant and a bookkeeper. In other words, a hacker is someone who looks at the high level big picture while a coder is someone who just dives in the code and makes changes (possibly under the direction of a hacker).
Re: by arctangent on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @12:23PM (#2490006)
I agree with your assessment.

I've always thought that a "hacker" operates at a higher level of abstraction and/or with a broader base of knowledge to draw upon (especially from unrelated fields) than does a mere "doer".

I think there's a need for both types of people in any large team, so one type isn't necessarily better than another in all circumstances.

However, in a small team (or startup) I think hackers are much more valuable due to their generalist nature. You can always hire code monkeys later to patch edge-case bugs and polish things up :-)

Disclaimer: I'm a hacker, so maybe I'm biased...

Re: by dansingerman on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @12:20PM (#2490000)
Smells of bullshit and wrongness to me.

The final link is a tell: to http://keynotopia.com/ - a tool for turning powerpoint into clickable mockups.

Edit: would appreciate a reference to the startup weekend mentioned.

Re: by bcrescimanno on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @12:25PM (#2490016)
Flagged the story based on this; it really screams "advertisement" to me.
Re: by silentbicycle on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @12:27PM (#2490021)
Same here, this reads like an ad written specifically for HN.
Re: by valisystem on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @12:31PM (#2490039)
clearly. The article is here to appeal people in 'becoming hackers', because you know, hackers are so happy in creating great click through prototypes.
Re: by lux on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @12:32PM (#2490043)
So is the lesson simply to prototype on paper/other mockup tool before coding?

Even in high school comp sci our teacher drilled this into us. We even wrote 100% of our coding tests on paper, no computers allowed. As a result, I still mock not just screens and flow between them on paper, but also data structures, logic, etc as well. Immensely helpful. And I keep going back to paper for revisions and exploring/testing changes/ideas as well. It's easy to show someone a paper mockup and easy enough to get them to "test" it too.

Re: by swombat on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @12:34PM (#2490053)
Unlike the rest of the comments so far, I don't think this article is "bunk".

A startup is a series of untested hypotheses, and testing those is how you make progress. When you look at an actual, real startup idea, in practice, maybe 10% of the critical early hypotheses require coding (and you probably won't get to those in the first weekend).

So yes, it may be a thinly veiled advertisemen for Keynotopia, but the point is still sound.

Being an entrepreneur and being a coder require very different mindsets. Just because you can code up an awesome webapp doesn't mean that product will be something anyone wants to use or buy.

Re: by amirkhella on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @12:30PM (#2490035)
Apologies for the promo link at the end of the post. The story wasn't meant to promote the product.
Re: by thekevan on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @12:40PM (#2490072)
I don't know, you saw people being successful doing something that your product does. You were validated. Maybe it would have been better to post this on the product blog but I am behind you on this.