News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Questions you should ask your interviewer by ams6110 on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @10:24AM (#2489569)
A non-compete is reasonable but it should also have a reasonable term... e.g. while employed, and perhaps for a period of 2 years after leaving.

That said, overly restrictive non-competes tend to be unenforceable, but I agree you don't want the hassle of a legal fight even if you ultimately prevail.

Re:Questions you should ask your interviewer by SkyMarshal on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @12:20PM (#2489999)
It also depends on the job. For a high-level executive position with a multi-million dollar golden parachute, sure a one or two year NCA is reasonable. For example, iirc Mark Hurd had to wait a year for NCA to expire before going to work at Oracle after leaving HP.

But for a professional developer/engineer position for with minimum severance it's completely unreasonable. It's like asking a lawyer to not practice law for a year after leaving a firm, or a doctor not to practice medicine for two years after leaving a partnership. That's your bread & butter, how you feed your children, and the idea of asking someone in that situation not to ply their hard-earned skills in their trade is nuts.

The only exception would be, and I personally agreed to this at my first job after graduating from college, is if the company provided an extensive training program that taught you all the skills you know. My first company provided three months all-day classroom/lab training while paying us full wages, then an additional three months of mixed OTJ and classroom/training. I was Econ grad and they taught us app development, and then asked us to sign a 1-year NCA that started on the date our training officially ended. They just wanted to make sure they didn't make a huge investment training people (and paying them full salary during training) who would then jump over to a competitor right afterwards, which was totally reasonable.

Later, another company asked me to sign an NCA that would go into effect my last day of work with them, but offered no training, professional development, or year-long severance. I and another new developer sat down with the CEO and explained the above, and she cancelled the whole program after realizing our side of it, which was very cool of her.

So yeah, it depends on the situation, type of employee, etc.

Re:Questions you should ask your interviewer by ultrasaurus on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @10:54AM (#2489679)
The last one of those I was asked to sign was laughably broad (the specific example I asked, was "What if I wrote a children's book" and yes, that would be covered). I asked to take it to my lawyer to review, and they forgot to ever ask for it again.
Re:Questions you should ask your interviewer by mgkimsal on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @11:32AM (#2489809)
2 years?! 1 is excessive in my view. Now, if I was paid handsomely for those 2 years, fine. But to not pay me and say I can't go work at other competitors - that's too much to ask for 2 years. I've had a couple 6 month non-competes - that's liveable. 1 year - I'd probably do it. 2 years? I doubt I'd sign.
Re:Questions you should ask your interviewer by semanticist on Wednesday April 27, 2011 @06:01PM (#2491276)
As a call centre drone I was required to sign a non-compete for Nokia saying that I wouldn't work for any other mobile phone manufacturer for a period of three years.

In practice I no one cared what their phone goons did after they left, but I suspect it was applied to everyone they hired, either directly or through outsourcing (like I was).

In fact, after the outsourcer lost the contract several of the people I worked with immediately went to do phone support for Samsung or Motorola (all three were in the same building).