News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New nuclear engine concept could help realize 3-month tri... by dmurray on Monday October 26, 2020 @07:17AM (#24894894)
This sounds like a matter of scale. A nuclear spaceship (a theoretical one, like all of them) with twice the thrust wouldn't be carrying twice the dead weight.

So at some level of scale this outperforms a traditional rocket, and your oddly impassioned argument about why SpaceX is so much better is just relevant to particular use cases rather than spaceship design in general.

Re:New nuclear engine concept could help realize 3-month tri... by valuearb on Monday October 26, 2020 @09:50AM (#24896122)
Scaling up low thrust to weight engines with large cooling and shielding requirements doesn’t create many mass efficiencies. Maybe in the shielding, but that’s the least of your concerns.

The other problem is that low thrust to weight means an NTR spade ship can’t land on Mars, or on any body with a significant gravity well. So you need to bring chemical rocket landers, increasing your mass duplication and tech complications.

A multipurpose chemical rocket powered space ship Luke Star Ship is far more practical and nearly as fast.